My quest for an Intel 1155 low profile CPU cooler!

Soldato
Joined
8 Oct 2005
Posts
2,840
Location
Herefordshire (U.K.)
I recently replaced the motherboard in my Silverstone Sugo SG04-F case with an Asus ROG model, and a 2500K processor on board.

As owners of this particular case will know, there is a space limitation of about 80mm between the CPU and the underside of the PSU for the cooler fan, and although the standard Intel cooler will fit in there OK, and I don't plan to overclock to extreme levels, I wanted to use something slightly better.

My first thought was to use an existing Zalman CNP58700 NT cooler which had been fitted to the previous mobo, but the close proximity of the heatsinks to the CPU socket didn't leave enough clearance for the 'holding down' clips etc. so that was a non-starter.

After a bit of research I first purchased an Akasa AK-CC7117EP01 K32 High Performance cooler and fan, which although fitted OK space wise, uses those silly Intel 'push-pin fixings which absolutely refused to 'click' into place... and which I hate anyone... and I am sure I am not the only one!

In the end I admitted defeat, and RMA'd it, and it was back to the drawing board (or in my case to Google!) for an alternative option. Now, I know that a lot of folks on here use, and recommend the Scythe Shuriken Rev.B but for some reason it just doesn't appeal to me. Partly because of the 100mm fans, and again it uses those horrible 'push pins' for fixing.

Further searching eventually produced a model I had never heard of before, namely the Samuel 17 from Prolimatech, (named of course after a chapter in the Bible’s Old Testament, concerning the story of David versus Goliath!) which had received some quite promising reviews, one of which can be found at http://www.swemod.com/swemod/page/review/20110216_prolimatech_samuel_17_prolimatech/1/ This cooler is not unfortunately currently stocked by OcUK, and there did actually only appear to be two currently available in the country (there is only one now) from outlets I was prepared to deal with, so an order was quickly placed!

I have to say that I am actually quite impressed with this little beauty. The quality of construction is very high, and the user is given the option of fitting any 120mm fan of his (or her) choice, with mounting screws being included for both 12 and 25mm deep fans. The height of the cooler itself is only 45mm, so I chose to use an Akasa Viper pwm fan with the s-flow blade design. Others will have their alternative favourites though, I am sure!

What also appealed to me about this product was that it is secured to the motherboard with four spring loaded screws, so by carefully supporting my board on two fairly high drawers I was able to fit them easily from underneath, without having to turn the board over, or hold the cooler in place. It could be positioned in several directions, and I finally chose one where the airflow from the fan would also help cool the heatsinks, leaving the RAM and the PCIe slots completely clear.

I haven't got round to carrying out real load testing yet, although the initial CPU temperature was about 27 degrees, which seemed quite encouraging, and I now looking forward to enjoying my new system!
 
Last edited:
Would be interested in seeing some temperature readings.

I'm not a fan of the Corsair Hydro series having the fan blow out of front. So it's good to have a list of traditional air coolers to consider.
 
wow i like it thanks for this
you know they could have easily extended the bracket so it could fit a 14cm fan too, that annoys me
still looks like a great cooler, agree about the Scythe
 
I like this quest; i'm following a similar one. I'm currently using a Thermaltake x3 slim, but it only supports up to 75w - will be getting an i5-2320 next week, which is 95w.
Any suggestions from the OCUK community?
 
Surely the Scythe series are recommended. If you can fit it the Scythe Big Shuriken 1 or 2 is the one to go for, needs 58mm clearance to be used. If you have less then I have seen good stuff on the Scythe Kozuti which only needs 40mm clearance, but the downside is it only has an 80mm fan versus the Big Shuriken with a 120mm fan.

DecipherXX,
Looks like your current one is 51mm tall, think you have 7mm more space above? If so I would go for the Scythe Big Shuriken 1 or 2 without a doubt.
 
That looks ideal - had a chance to properly measure the depth and i have a maximum of 90mm between the board and power supply so this should fit, thanks saitrix.

But theres a problem - the amount of space around the CPU socket is tiny, my current replacement cooler (A 1U Akasa thing) can only be used in reverse, ie blowing air the wrong way.

Anyone got this cooler in a tiny setup?
 
That looks ideal - had a chance to properly measure the depth and i have a maximum of 90mm between the board and power supply so this should fit, thanks saitrix.

But theres a problem - the amount of space around the CPU socket is tiny, my current replacement cooler (A 1U Akasa thing) can only be used in reverse, ie blowing air the wrong way.

Anyone got this cooler in a tiny setup?

I think a lot will depend on what the airflow is like in your case, as with the Akasa cooler you mention, one website says "The long life two-ball bearing fan draws the cool air though the fins and extracts hot air to one side to support chassis airflow."

I have currently got my fan installed so that it blows 'down' onto the CPU, but as the PSU is fairly close to the top of it I had actually wondered whether it might be more efficient the other way round, i.e 'pulling' the air up from the CPU so that the PSU fan could then 'grab it' and extract it outside the case.

Problem is, I am not really sure which temperatures I should be keeping an eye on... both the CPU and the MB, I suppose!

I am still quite taken with my 'Samuel 17' cooler though.... especially with the 120mm fan!
 
Last edited:
I'm in 2 minds what to do with my PSU, I've turned it over so it's taking air from thin gap between it and case side panel.
Think I may revert to how it was but reverse the fan.

I went for the Scythe Big Shuriken 2, installed last night and was pleasantly surprised with how much noise was reduced. :)
Temperatures are still on the wrong side of 55 degrees though. :(
 
I'm in 2 minds what to do with my PSU, I've turned it over so it's taking air from thin gap between it and case side panel.
Think I may revert to how it was but reverse the fan.

I went for the Scythe Big Shuriken 2, installed last night and was pleasantly surprised with how much noise was reduced. :)
Temperatures are still on the wrong side of 55 degrees though. :(

How much power do you need, whats your specs? Could always go for a picopsu?
 
I went for the Scythe Big Shuriken 2, installed last night and was pleasantly surprised with how much noise was reduced. :)
Temperatures are still on the wrong side of 55 degrees though. :(

Are you talking about CPU temperatures here... if so, is that under 'normal' or 'full load' conditions?
 
I chucked on winrar test (PC is pretty much just a Windows install and that) then went away for a couple of hours...
Came back for a look at had hit 59, was actually hoping for cooler. If I had a better test on there, it would probably be over 60.
Not sure when I'll get time to reverse the fan and have PSU exhaust out all the heat, will see if it drops temps though.

Edit: Oh... Not on Intel btw! Just liked to read this thread whilst I was looking for low profile AM3.
 
I chucked on winrar test (PC is pretty much just a Windows install and that) then went away for a couple of hours...
Came back for a look at had hit 59, was actually hoping for cooler. If I had a better test on there, it would probably be over 60.
Not sure when I'll get time to reverse the fan and have PSU exhaust out all the heat, will see if it drops temps though.

Edit: Oh... Not on Intel btw! Just liked to read this thread whilst I was looking for low profile AM3.

What's the issue with the temps then. :confused: That's totally fine, I have mine hitting 60 often when under load. If you get it lower all you are doing is creating more noise then needed, as it is cool enough to be safe already.
 
I'm in 2 minds what to do with my PSU, I've turned it over so it's taking air from thin gap between it and case side panel.
Think I may revert to how it was but reverse the fan.

I went for the Scythe Big Shuriken 2, installed last night and was pleasantly surprised with how much noise was reduced. :)
Temperatures are still on the wrong side of 55 degrees though. :(

sorry for the lag but did you find it hard to install. I'm a socket 1155 and i Find it quite impossible to get the screws on with the memory installed which it has to be as you dont have enough room to install it afterwards on the asus P8Z68 M PRO
 
Plenty room for the components on the top of the board, the cooler mount does cover some chips on the underside of the mobo though.
It's not caused a problem as there is some padded stuff that stops any damage being done, but... I'd prefer if this wasn't the case.
 
Back
Top Bottom