New monitor not sure what to go for

Associate
Joined
23 Dec 2010
Posts
75
Hello so my trusty 10 year old lg monitor has finally died and im currently stuck using a Philips E-line 234EL2SB which is also about 6 years old or so? It's seriously time I get a good gaming monitor while I have the funds for it. Gaming on one monitor is actually driving me nuts.

The pc I have at the moment is pretty decent 980 though I will be looking to upgrade it next year or so. My go to game is usually mainly WoW but I do play fps and other random titles from time to time.

Ive been looking at some monitors and the new LG seems to be a great choice but im really not sure if I should splash the cash and go for a widescreen or super widescreen, I do have around 1000 to spend but I would rather go for the best monitor regardless of size or such. Is the new LG the way to go bang for buck or shall I go for more?
 
Hi

Just gone super widescreen myself i bought the Alienware AW3418DW for £900 and its has so far exceeded all my expectations i only wish i had gone super wide sooner.

I considered the LG34GK950G at £999 to but the Alienware was £100 cheaper has the Dell name behind it and was well received in reviews.
 
Ultrawide. The only question is how wide.
For £1000, you can either go for the AW3418DW or the CRG9. The other monitors which are a bit more expensive will give you an extra 24hz or a very new backlight tech which seems to be a bit meh.


Definitley go ultrawide though.
 
Sweet is the ultrawide really that much better over a plain monitor you guys reckon? Also does going from 4ms to 1ms really make that much of a difference?
Id be willing to spend a bit more, if the monitor is going to be a much better investment for the extra 100 or so then id spend it but id like to be on the 1000.
Theres so many different monitors, im a touch overwhelmed, also as I understand depending on the monitor I get, im probably locked into nvidia or amd then?
 
Sweet is the ultrawide really that much better over a plain monitor you guys reckon? Also does going from 4ms to 1ms really make that much of a difference?
Id be willing to spend a bit more, if the monitor is going to be a much better investment for the extra 100 or so then id spend it but id like to be on the 1000.
Theres so many different monitors, im a touch overwhelmed, also as I understand depending on the monitor I get, im probably locked into nvidia or amd then?


I've went from 16:9 monitor to 4k 65inch 16:9 TV to 21:9 monitor and I've used a 32:9 monitor in store for about an hour.


Now ontop my opinion on spending more than £1000 is that we're kind of split in regards to how everyone is moving forwards with ultrawide technology. Samsung have their CRG9 which favours 32:9. A few of the big boys have 1.5k and 2.5k monitors which use FALD backlights but have some blooming issues (I find it hard to tolerate this in such an expensive device). LG are releasing a 38 inch 29:10 monitor. I don't think any specific monitor for over £1000 is going to leave you better re: day to day experience of the monitor. IMO get the best VALUE 21:9 monitor you can get which has a 100hz + refresh rate.
In regards to Gsync vs Freesync. Gsync ties you into Nvidia cards. Some Freesync monitors play well with Nvidia cards and allow adaptive sync.
Given these monitors are quite high resolution and high refresh rate, realistically speaking IMO (in my opinion) 90% of users will be using Nvidia cards so I'd prioritise them playing well with Nvidia cards. Some freesync ultrawides do, some don't.
Just ignore HDR on these monitors IMO if you've used an OLED or FALD TV.


I think the monitors you should be looking for at £1k are:
1. AW 3418DW
2. CRG 9
3. LG 34-F

The AW has the best warranty period with a brilliant return and replace program. Dell are known for their customer service; LG and Samsung aren't. Its 120hz, IPS, Gsync.
The LG 34-F has a wider colour gamut, newer panel and has an extra 24hz. Its been documented that there have been a fair few quality concerns (just search on this forum) and LG aren't that well known for their customer service.. lol. Its Freesync but works with Gsync so you aren't tied to Nvidia.

So between the two, prioritise if you'd rather have the 24hz and a newer panel with potentially higher colour depth for the content you might use or the better customer service and build quality. I would not have HDR factor into the decision because the LG has redundantly poor HDR performance, just like very screen without a dedicated backlight or OLED. Also if you hate Nvidia, the LG is a no brainer but I'm not sure which card you'd buy from AMD outside of the Radeon VII whcih will power it to 144hz.

Now we move onto the CRG 9. Its 32:9, and therefore its very demanding. It has a weird aspect ratio which is much wider, much more immersive but it is VERY big. Using it for normal desktop use caused me to have neckstrain as I was literally turning my head to different parts of the screen but for gaming, its quite amazing. Its like that extra jump from 21:9. It is freesync but plays well with nvidia cards adaptive sync.


So...

Is 21:9 worth it? Yes. 21:9 feels like what PC monitor gaming should be. 4k TV 65 inch was amazing for me. I' loved it for the bigger screen immersion but 21:9 with a higher refresh rate beats it. Its strange but I almost feel some sensations like falling at times which is quite cool. It looks plain better and games stop feeling cramped and look much more cinematic. The con is which games don't work with it. Most games do, and its a popular format so hacks are available. 21:9 monitors also make films and 21:9 youtube videos look amazing. Navigating and using the screen is almost perfect. No neck turning.


Is 32:9 worth it? I used it for a short while and I LOVED it. I didn't get one because it requires huge graphical grunt, it wouldn't fit on my desk without me sacrificng speaker placement and therefore sound quality and it's compataibility is really hit and miss. I've researched it for hours and the games I'm about to play on my 21:9 monitor just have no documented fixes or patches available online. You can switch it to a 21:9 custom resolution but meh.. black bars are black bars. also using a 32:9 i imagine would take ahuge learning curve of moving your head a lot... I struggled to find the mouse pointer when I used it.




I'm going to summarise what I've said in a shorter sentance because I've probably bored you do death and you've skipped most of that.

My experience is 16:9 feels cramped now and just doesn't feel right. Games feel like games.
21:9 feels immersive and it feels right. It doesn't feel like too much, it feels like the perfect ammount.
32:9 feels really immersive but has its teething problems as you can imagine, just not many people own a 32:9 montior.


I have a 21:9 now and contemplating changing to 32:9 because basically I'm just weird and always want more.

If you're not an AMD fanboy or an Nvidia hater, just make sure the monitor plays well with Nvidia because they're the ones who are going to be pushing the graphical grunt for these higher end displays whilst price gouging us along the way. I don't think AMD are going to be able to power the CRG9 anytime soon compared to what Nvidia will offer next year.
 
Wow thanks that, great read.
The CRG 9 looks great but powering that beast up and going from a 23 inch to 49 might be bit much. Quite a pity to read about the LG customer service and faults considering I had my old one for a decade with 0 problems. I must admit even though my LG monitor was older than the one im using now, the colors in it always looked far better.
I was really looking to go LG but after looking into it, the AW really does seem great. The only thing im considering now is to choose one of them or grab a 27GL850, which would be a better monitor spec wise?
I did just see a picture of the samsung monitor in another thread and it does look great.
 
Wow thanks that, great read.
The CRG 9 looks great but powering that beast up and going from a 23 inch to 49 might be bit much. Quite a pity to read about the LG customer service and faults considering I had my old one for a decade with 0 problems. I must admit even though my LG monitor was older than the one im using now, the colors in it always looked far better.
I was really looking to go LG but after looking into it, the AW really does seem great. The only thing im considering now is to choose one of them or grab a 27GL850, which would be a better monitor spec wise?
I did just see a picture of the samsung monitor in another thread and it does look great.

The Samsung's main flaws would be: powering the monitor, games which support the resolution, desk space, price, fish eye in games, the fact the resolution is very rare so finding hacks online is 100x harder than 21:9, dead pixel complaints from owners. Yeah, between the LG and the AW, its a matter of 24hz + wider colour gamut vs better build quality, customer service and warranty? I personally edge towards the AW everytime because I've dealt with dell's customer service before and its impeccable.

On the member's market, there are two AW341DW's up for sale (I'm selling one for £700). The warranty is transferrable so its a really good starting point if you want to buy a high end ultrawide monitor but save £300-450. I don't think there will be a better value 21:9 display for the next 24 months. Sure monitors will be released in the £1100+ range but none will touch it within the £700 range and I think all the newer models will hold their price.
 
Bit conflicted now whether to go ultrawide or 16:9, does 2 windows fit comfortably in one? I was also looking at the LG 34GK90F, is it worth the money compared to the others?
Just debating whether to bite the bullet and get one now or wait for the 16:9 LG and save some money.
 
Two windows fits absolutely fine, no problems, but I find the 1000€+ screens abit overpriced (if u compare their image quality to an OLED they are so overpriced), I got two 500€ ultrawides instead Acer Z35P for my main screen and Acer CZ350CK as secondary, then I can be sure I dont run out of room, lets say I play on one screen and the second can have 2 or 3 other windows open of whatever I need, they are vertically stacked so there is no need to keep waving ur head from side to side.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom