However, it doesn't look THAT bad at all, and i think people have been unduly harsh.
Not really IMO. It looked like it had promise in the first (mockup) pic, before the tablet was securely fixed, before it had "sponge" to stop it vibrating and to close the gap that was already slightly too large for the tablet's screen.
Then it was fitted, some things were changed, and the foam/sponge added, which is blatently obvious. Not to mention the fact that since you can't use the thing without palming it all the time, it's always going to look a grubby mess. Matt screens are used in cars for a reason

It looks utter crud here, even excusing the fingerprints (which will come back within minutes of cleaning it, unless you intend on never touching the thing?).