Nvidia 3d Vision - initial verdict on some games

Soldato
Joined
26 Dec 2005
Posts
16,172
Location
Paisley
I got my 3d vision up and running last night.

The kit - Alienware 23" 120hz monitor, nvidia 3d vision glasses, gtx 580.

After a relatively easy setup, i got stuck into some games. I havent played much for long, just long enough to get a feel for the glasses and to see where things benefit, or lose out on account of the glasses.

I have most of the games on nvidia's list of supported games, granted, there's not many that are officially branded, so i gave these ones a go first.

Just Cause 2 - The look of this was excellent, really added something to the game, the effect when the parachute opens is superb. Im looking forward to replaying through this with 3d enabled.

Metro 2033 - Wow, simply wow. I have never before had such an immersive experience, where im at in the game, this was the game that really blew me away, the only downside i had some bad motion sickness playing this, hopefully with a few tweaks ill be able to get rid of this (i quite often get motion sickness playing these types of games anyway).

Civ V - This is interesting, i found it quite dark, the 3d effect was good, but i didnt think the kind of game really lent itself to 3d.

Battlefield BC2 - Only played the intro, but like Metro 2033, really immersive for third person games, i can see this being the area where the glasses will be used most, going on the boats to the landing site again had me wobbling with motion sickness.

I then moved on to some other games that were rated in a variety of different classes. I should say, when you load a game, you get a box in the corner which tells you what rating the game has, and what to turn off to get the best experience.

Grid - This told me to turn a few options off, but i couldnt find the options to do this. Its rated excellent, but something wasnt right with it, and it was unplayable to me.

Assasins Creed 2 - Similar to Just Cause 2, was an excellent effect walking around the crowd.

Super Meat Boy - As this is my newest game, i thought id give it a try, the 3d effect was excellent and i felt added something to it, the platforms standing out.

That's everything ive tried so far, first person shooters look the best, but for me, unless i can get used to it and conquer the motion sickness, i doubt ill be able to play long with it, i was feeling a bit crook last night myself, which probably didnt help. I wont be using it with every game just for the sake of it, over the weekend ill try a variety of other games (im downloading batman again as its rated as supported), and will give Starcraft 2 and maybe lord of the rings a go to see how these work.
 
Thanks for the review, I'm leaning towards 3D myself, the only worry I have is going from an IPS panel to a TN, what monitor did you have previously?
 
Great thread thanks. Still trying to justify the extra cash on a 3d ready monitor and whether or not I want 3D involved with online play where reactions are important and if 3d has an effect on that in anyway
 
I previously had ocuk's DGM with a PVA panel (same as a dell 2407) I was worried about this myself, I initially ran them side by side (i got the monitor a few weeks ago), but ive been happy with the quality, looking straight on the quality is on a par with the PVA, but viewing angles arent great, fortunately the stand is adjustable on the alienware, so if im lounging back, i can easily adjust it to suit.

I bought the alienware to get the 120hz (got it second hand off the MM for £200), then my 5850 was struggling to hit 120fps in games, which is why i upgraded the graphics, i was 2/3 of the way to 3d then, so thought id give it a crack.
 
Hmmmmm, i was hoping you were gonna say how bad it was haha. my upgrade list gets bigger and bigger everyday now. I was looking into these last night, gonna sell my ps3 since its been collecting dust for the past 8+ months, pc speakers are new but i dont really like them so they'll get sold too. might as well get rid of this moniter too haha, still uses a vga plug, it'll be almost as if i've skipped dvi altogether and gone from vga to hdmi haha. so i guess that money will go towards a new moniter + 3d vision.
 
good review. Try running benchmarks like super sled demo, endless city and hevan benchmark. Also try the medusa 3d preview. (all in 3d, super sled demo is just amazing.)

keep up to date with the nvidia 3d world. http://3dvision-blog.com/ gives you a lot of exellent preview clips for nvidia 3d vision users. You will enjoy it more if you look through that blog for movies etc.
 
I'm not going 3D until I can get a monitor with as good a colour response and wide angle as my Dell 2209WA. I just can't go back to TN panels now.
 
How much of a perfomance hit are you having running a game in 3d? I heard that official 3d games get a 20% while non official games get a 50% hit. Is this matching up with your experiences?
 
"Metro 2033 - Wow, simply wow"
Gotta agree with this - it blew me away too. Nasty one with your motion sickness though, I thought I may suffer with that when I got my setup but thankfully I have had no problem. You might want to try holding CTL and F5 in game to reduce convergence a bit. The only FPS game that has ever made me feel ill was HL2 (in non 3d) I think the PoV was too narrow and this made me very ill within 5 mins :(

You should pick up Batman AA if you haven't already, its superb in 3d and a decent game to boot :P
Oh and Mafia 2 was great! OH and also grab Left4dead - also awesome :)
 
"Metro 2033 - Wow, simply wow"
Gotta agree with this - it blew me away too. Nasty one with your motion sickness though, I thought I may suffer with that when I got my setup but thankfully I have had no problem. You might want to try holding CTL and F5 in game to reduce convergence a bit. The only FPS game that has ever made me feel ill was HL2 (in non 3d) I think the PoV was too narrow and this made me very ill within 5 mins :(

You should pick up Batman AA if you haven't already, its superb in 3d and a decent game to boot :P
Oh and Mafia 2 was great! OH and also grab Left4dead - also awesome :)

Yes, I read yesterday about adjusting convergence, so will give that a go.

I installed Batman yesterday, but got bored waiting for the intro to walk, but it looks extremely good.

The motion sickness is less of a probem now, i was feeling quite ill on Friday anyway when i tried them out, i had the same problem with half life 2 a few years ago.
 
some games cross hairs are not centered but nvidia has added there own 3d crosshairs to games that are bugged.

yeah but if your eyes are focussing on something close and the crosshairs are at a very far distance or vice versa, your eyes are going to see 2 the crosshairs both sides of the centre... this was the main problem I had with FPS games and the nvidia 'laser' thing didn't completely fix the problem
 
Back
Top Bottom