Soldato
why do u want chris dead, that is twice now you have just voted chris, any real reason why you want to lynch him or are you like pookie last game with your "niggles"
OcUK Mafia game thread -Game 5
- Thread starter iviv
- Start date
why do u want chris dead, that is twice now you have just voted chris, any real reason why you want to lynch him or are you like pookie last game with your "niggles"
Caporegime
Town is entirely quiet today then suddenly a nomination out of nowhere :/
Brabbs you posted earlier "However it now gives me a couple of faint suspicions to keep an eye on. "
Chris asked you to elaborate but all you've really done is say you have suspicions. What are they, and why? You're nominating Chris but if you want others to vote for him you need to convince us why you think he's mafia.
Brabbs you posted earlier "However it now gives me a couple of faint suspicions to keep an eye on. "
Chris asked you to elaborate but all you've really done is say you have suspicions. What are they, and why? You're nominating Chris but if you want others to vote for him you need to convince us why you think he's mafia.
Soldato
yeah this is what im on about, he seems to just want chris dead for no reason
Associate
- Joined
- 7 Jan 2010
- Posts
- 886
It's fair enough to raise suspicions, and to be fair he did give a reason that my tone is different from last game, but I have responded in detail to that. I definitely got the impression that people weren't keen on my tone from last game (sorry about that!) so I have tried to change that.
After I explained it, then you vote for me with no further reasoning. Do you disbelieve me? Is there something else?
After I explained it, then you vote for me with no further reasoning. Do you disbelieve me? Is there something else?
Soldato
hmm..... Maybe Brabb is the tracker, his day one vote was a valid reason, chris hadn't posted. Day 2 is somewhat out of place, so the only reason i can think of him voting for chris is he has tracked him and is thinking of any reason to vote for him.
Associate
- Joined
- 26 Jan 2006
- Posts
- 2,039
If he is the tracker and found a definite scum he could sacrifice himself by revealing this.
Soldato
yeah exactly, tbh think until he explains himself he has sacrificed himself atm
Before your behaviour was a bit aggressive and suspicious to me. Now though, I hope you're not town. Don't tell everyone if you think someone is a special role for the town, you'll just get them killed. The mafia may not have even begun thinking Brabbs could have been the tracker!
Soldato
Yes, if brabb is the tracker, he can tell us, the jailer can keep him alive by picking him and if chris is mafia then that is one down, one to go.
But if the jailer keeps Brabbs alive, and he is the tracker, then Brabbs can't track!!!
Soldato
- Joined
- 24 Apr 2011
- Posts
- 5,455
I kind iof agree with the chris vote. It's him or Fortyseven for me (I voted for him day one too).
I'll try re-read, but if I don't manage, I'll go for Chris.
I'll try re-read, but if I don't manage, I'll go for Chris.
Caporegime
So either:
Brabbs isn't tracker, in which case his nomination is a touch suspicious
Brabbs is the tracker and he knows Chris is mafia in which case he can come clean and we can trade 1:1
Brabbs is the tracker and he doesn't know but is just going on a hunch with Chris, in which case...he's now in a tough position
Brabbs isn't tracker, in which case his nomination is a touch suspicious
Brabbs is the tracker and he knows Chris is mafia in which case he can come clean and we can trade 1:1
Brabbs is the tracker and he doesn't know but is just going on a hunch with Chris, in which case...he's now in a tough position
Soldato
if he is the tracker guaranteed townie, it is someone off the list and if the mafia try to kill brabb its a wasted kill and whats to stop the jailer getting up to some hi-jinx. the jailer saves someone else, the mafia trys to kill them, tracker gets a track through and maybe someone is saved
Soldato
* a wasted kill if the jailer saves him
My vote is just a hunch. And no more than that. But at least it has got some conversation going.mainly based off the fact he is playing a different game to the previous one. The style seems a more fly under the radar effort.
On day 1 I voted for him as he hadn't been partaking in the game. Once he did I switched to voting for Jaystation. So don't read into a pattern with my votes.
If someone can provide a valid alternative I'll happily reconsider
Read into my actions as you will, but just remember a quiet town leads to a dead town
On day 1 I voted for him as he hadn't been partaking in the game. Once he did I switched to voting for Jaystation. So don't read into a pattern with my votes.
If someone can provide a valid alternative I'll happily reconsider
Read into my actions as you will, but just remember a quiet town leads to a dead town
Associate
- Joined
- 26 Jan 2006
- Posts
- 2,039
Yeah, ther only way a tracker (IMO) should reveal themselves is if they are 100% someone is scum.
It is then up to the jailer to decide what to do going forward, but protecting the tracker indefinitly is fruitless.
We don't want to be openly speculating who is the tracker at any point as this will just help the Mafia.
Two days running Brabbs has been the first to vote to get discussion going. I see this (currently) as pro-town.
Associate
- Joined
- 7 Jan 2010
- Posts
- 886
I actually agree with this, despite being the target. However, I'm not the right target because a) I'm town and b) I don't think there is the will to lynch me amongst the rest of the town based on a meta read which has been explained.
Brab may well be the tracker but clearly didn't get any evidence on me from last night or he'd have said so. Ultimately that's just speculation until he (or someone else) reveals themselves.
So here's my deductions for today
Brab has lead the charge twice - too brave to be mafia barring WIFOM shenans. TOWN
Leprechaun has leapt to my defence. Given that I'm town, there's no reason for mafia to do this. TOWN
Malteser - I have previously stated I don't think its worth reading anything into the RNG idea, too aggressive on day 1 to be mafia. You need to do that re-read though and continue contributing. TOWN
Shami I find hard to read, he has come across townie mostly but I see him having a good poker face so can never be sure. TOWN/NEUTRAL
Fortyseven I don't like a few of his posts (I may do a Post By Post Analysis later) but the last couple of his posts have been better. NEUTRAL/SCUM
Pudney seems quite on the fence throughout both days, which is classic active lurking from what I've seen, but from what I remember that's how Pudney posts even when he's town. NEUTRAL/SCUM
Based on this and the dwindling hours, I'll put my money where my mouth is and go with
VOTE: Fortyseven
And that's exactly my point!
Associate
- Joined
- 26 Jan 2006
- Posts
- 2,039
Yeah, I was agreeing with you. I personally think you are town but chris' post above has his finger pointed firmly at us.
I'm not saying he is not town just misguided. I'll have another look at posts later when I'm not on my phone.
Caporegime
I agree with most of what Chris says, I'm not so sure about Malteser yet though. His first day posting style to me felt a little over confident, whether just an eager townie or an overcompensating mafia I'm not sure yet.
Chris is difficult to read, a point to consider is if he does turn out to be mafia then Leprechaun defending him throws him into suspicion to.
It's fairly unlikely both Brabbinho and Chris are mafia (unless they are doing a huge bluff) Brabbinho has been a bit too aggressive to be mafia but then that could be the reaction he's hoping for.
Chris is difficult to read, a point to consider is if he does turn out to be mafia then Leprechaun defending him throws him into suspicion to.
It's fairly unlikely both Brabbinho and Chris are mafia (unless they are doing a huge bluff) Brabbinho has been a bit too aggressive to be mafia but then that could be the reaction he's hoping for.