Official OcUK Tyre Review & Guide thread!

Indeed but getting reasonably priced, decent quality, good looking, staggered fitment, correct offset wheels is hard. Should have gone for the falkens I think :(

I have the 912s and they seem alright, but I have very little to compare them to as my previous car was a Clio. And the 912s were on the turbo when I bought it.
 
I'm trying to think what I can possibly write about my tyres that isn't just going to be bullcarp hyperbole.

Well if you had different tyres on previously you could write how they compare, but if you did not well there is not really much you can write as you have nothing to compare too. ;)
 
Falken 452
Car - Focus ST
Tyre size - 245/40/18
Previous tyre - Goodyear F1 Asymmetric
Dry Grip - very good, cant tell any difference than the f1
Dry braking - good no wobbling
Wet Grip - fine while driving normally starts to give when you push it in cornors
Wet braking - very good for the price, but think the F1s are better in this area
Sidewall - Very solid much stiffer than the F1s, had no pinches with these on potholes, had to replace F1s on two occasions due to pinches
Turn in - ok nothing to write home about
Feedback - great loads of feedback can really feel the road
Comfort - much louder than the f1s at motorway speeds can really hear the changing road surfaces

Summary - For the money its hands down they are best tyre out there for budget. I rate them better than the F1s as they last longer and are less likely to be pinched on potholes. I would definitely buy again

Let me counter that with my thoughts with the same tyre, on the same car except in the correct size (225/40/18).

Falken FK452
Car - Focus ST
Tyre size - 225/40/18
Previous tyre - Avon ZZ5 / P-Zero Nero
Dry Grip - Very good until they get down to around 4mm, where they take a pretty hard fall in performance IMO. That said, whilst they grip they offer little feedback.
Dry braking - On par with the dry grip review.
Wet Grip - I really liked their behaviour in the wet, there was decent grip available and when they reached their limit they let go very progressively. But, again the wet performance suffered as they wore.
Wet braking - It worked (I'm not sure how we can really judge braking unless a tyre is significantly better than another at it).
Sidewall - The sidewall is too soft IMO, I scrubbed the hell out of a lot of the sidewall at an autotest, and I had to run the tyres about 2-3PSI higher than the manufacturer spec. FWIW, I've bucked a wheel with one of these tyres on - not sure how they resist pothole "pinches" :confused:. I believe its also responsible for the next 2;
Turn in - It does it but lacks feel here, needed the pressure increase to be considered acceptable.
Feedback - Don't agree here, I thought the feedback lacked hugely.
Comfort - They were quieter than my old tyres, and in this size there is so little comfort provided by the tyre that its impossible to call. Going back to the P-Zero/ZZ5 when I sold the car, they felt a bit harder though, I suppose.

Summary - I wouldn't buy for a performance car again, but was happy enough with their grip levels to put them on our family car, perhaps. The fronts also wore really quick - I'm talking down to 4-4.5mm in the space of about 3000 miles.
 
Last edited:
Maxxis MAV1

Car - Ford Fiesta (Not a performance car, but you want your family safe? Right? )
Tyre size - 195/50/115
Previous Tyre - Pirreli p5000
Dry Grip - Real Grip, no sliding even around those tight country lanes.
Dry braking - Great, No hassle, Nice and straight, Great considering i don't have ABS.
Wet Grip - Again here, Brilliant compared to the Pirrelis, No sliding, and minimal wheel spin on pull off.
Wet braking - Very Good. Compared to the Pirrelis, amazing. No trouble and less drama.
Sidewall - No flexing, but yet good comfort as a whole. Not the hardest outthere.
Turn in - Good feel to it, inspires a lot of confidence.
Feedback - (Handed car over to tame experienced driver since i'm quite new, some say...) Old man says theyre on par with the old pirrelis for feel, don't make the car feel sluggish and you get a good feel of the tarmac underneath you.
Comfort - Quite a comfortable tyre, deals well with potholes and road surface issues.

Summary - This tyre is classed a budget tyre, But in both my and the old mans opinion these tyres are FAR better than than the 4 'Premium' Pirrelis we had on before. Good Grip, Nice ride, and £41 a corner Fitted. Will just have to see how long they last.
 
Last edited:
Maxxis MAV1

Dry Grip - Real Grip, no sliding even around those tight country lanes.
Dry braking - Great, No hassle, Nice and straight, Great considering i don't have ABS.
Wet Grip - Again here, Brilliant compared to the Pirrelis, No sliding, and minimal wheel spin on pull off.
Wet braking - Very Good. Compared to the Pirrelis, amazing. No trouble and less drama.
Sidewall - No flexing, but yet good comfort as a whole. Not the hardest outthere.
Turn in - Good feel to it, inspires a lot of confidence.

And this is everything thats wrong with this thread. This guy thinks his tyre is amazing, even though its very likely its amongst the poorest tyres out there. Why does he think its so good? Because he had P6000's before whicha re even worse.
 
My tyres are round and black no idea what make they are think they may be Nankang ? They operate perfect seeing as i dont speed or drive round corners quick. The size is 225/45/17 and are attached to my vectra Cdti which has been re-mapped to 190bhp but more for fuel economy than performance. Not sure that helps anyone but hey ho...
 
[TW]Fox;17686831 said:
And this is everything thats wrong with this thread. This guy thinks his tyre is amazing, even though its very likely its amongst the poorest tyres out there. Why does he think its so good? Because he had P6000's before whicha re even worse.

And they were old P6000s as well...

I have loads of mates who are very much into cars but who are convinced that budget tyres are just as good as good stuff and quite happy to put the likes of Nankangs on a Golf GTI and drive like a nutter. Comments like this abound:

'They're loads better than the Goodyear F1s I had on before, why spend more?'

Yes, but your F1s were worn down to the minimum. A brand new budget tyre is likely as good if not better than a barely legal premium tyre that was replaced - but comparing like for like with similar levels of wear the difference is clear.
 
My tyres are round and black no idea what make they are think they may be Nankang ? They operate perfect seeing as i dont speed or drive round corners quick. The size is 225/45/17 and are attached to my vectra Cdti which has been re-mapped to 190bhp but more for fuel economy than performance. Not sure that helps anyone but hey ho...

They may be fine for when you're driving along normally, but what about when you have to stop quickly in the rain to avoid something, swerve around a pothole or one of many common situations where braking distance and grip are paramount. The cheap tyres such as nankang are made from harder compounds which have compromised grip and poor braking distances. Tyres are the most important thing you can spend money on.
 
They may be fine for when you're driving along normally, but what about when you have to stop quickly in the rain to avoid something, swerve around a pothole or one of many common situations where braking distance and grip are paramount. The cheap tyres such as nankang are made from harder compounds which have compromised grip and poor braking distances. Tyres are the most important thing you can spend money on.

And how many crashes are caused by poor tyre choice/Cheap tyres... ?

My tires are fine they grip more than i will ever need and braking performance in the wet is perfectly fine. They meet EU standards and that is fine for me.
 
[TW]Fox;17687702 said:
How many are caused by loss of control?



EU Standards eh? Do you know what this actually means?

And how many are caused by loss of control due to using cheap road legal tyres..? Not many i can assure you.

Yes i do thanks. It means my cheap tyres will perform exactly as i expect them too. I drive within the limits of the road and i dont speed or drive like an idiot so they do exactly as they should. They have been on the car for 2 years, covered nearly 15k miles and caused no concerns in any weather.
 
And how many are caused by loss of control due to using cheap road legal tyres..? Not many i can assure you.

How many almost happen but don't due to the driver regaining grip?

Yes i do thanks. It means my cheap tyres will perform exactly as i expect them too.

Didn't think you did.

Go and read this:

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/Autocar-Tyre-Test-Budget-Tyre-Performance.htm

Senior tester Jamie Corstorphine summed up with: “We expected the bargain tyres in this test to fall short of the Continental, but we were not prepared for just how poorly some performed.”

The results are shocking.

The Linglong equipped VW Golf Autocar used for its tests was still doing 27.8mph at the point where it had stopped on the Continentals
 
[TW]Fox;17687774 said:
How many almost happen but don't due to the driver regaining grip?



Didn't think you did.

Go and read this:

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/Autocar-Tyre-Test-Budget-Tyre-Performance.htm

I can get you some accurate figures if you require. My best mate is a traffic officer and has been for 17 years..

So what you are saying is that in 16 years of driving, Owning 29 cars and 3 motorbikes and 2 caravans (sorry about that) that my judgment on tyres is not too your satisfaction and i should replace my perfectly good tyres with some more expensive obviously better ones for what reason exactly...???
 
His second quote is a prime example of why ditchfinders should be illegal.

EU standards mean squat, and much less for tyres!
 
Yeah you guys are right sorry I bow down to your supperior knowledge and will have my tyres replaced immediately.

Cheers for the advice
 
[TW]Fox;17687820 said:
No, you can't.



Would you like a badge, or a sticker?

Yes i can but hey ho you must be right so i cant..

Badge please, Stickers tend to loose grip in the wet and slide of all over the place, especially the cheap ones... :rolleyes:
 
[TW]Fox;17687928 said:
Why can you? 'Crappy chinese tyres' is never recorded as a reason for an accident, is it?

No but the cause is. So it could be lack of concentration, etc etc.. The proportion due to tryes is very low and most of them is due to poor maintenance, Under/over inflation damage to the tyre etc.. The tyres should perform perfectly well within the realms of safe driving which my Nankangs do perfectly fine...

Anyway who cares lets keep the thread on the topic of tyre reviews....
 
It's not that they cause accidents its that they prevent the avoidance of accidents or increase the severity of one.

If your braking distance is several car lengths longeer because you are so cheap, then its not beyond the realms of possibility to understand that a tyre can be the difference between a close one and a crash.
 
Back
Top Bottom