Onboard vs Sound Card

Associate
Joined
29 Dec 2005
Posts
145
Hi all,

Just wondering whether I would notice a big difference in sound quality (mainly aimed at gaming - seems I cant hear anything compared to others) with upgrading from my onboard sound vs a dedicated sound card? I use a Creative Fatal1ty headset if that matters too.

Onboard = Realtek® ALC892 8-Channel High Definition Audio CODEC (on Asus
p8z68-v pro mobo)

If there is a significant difference, what are typical recommended sound cards? (without spending a fortune, possibly ~£30-40)

Thanks in advance
 
Man of Honour
Joined
13 Oct 2006
Posts
90,805
At £30-40 you probably won't get better results from a sound card than onboard sound.

I'm currently using a Creative Sound BlasterX AE-5 which is currently £110-120 but it is definitely a step up over any onboard implementation I've used - clearer and punchier sound and has some good features for gaming.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2009
Posts
11,175
I'd stick with onboard audio, unless you want Dolby Headphone or SBX prostudio, or find the headset doesn't go loud enough with the onboard audio you have.
 
Soldato
Joined
6 Jun 2008
Posts
11,616
Location
Finland
seems I cant hear anything compared to others) with upgrading from my onboard sound vs a dedicated sound card? I use a Creative Fatal1ty headset if that matters too.
ALC892 is pretty much bottom of the product barrel codec.
Even Audigy Fx would be clear step higher in D/A conversion quality.
Xonar DGX is technically similar, but has that mediocre Dolby Headphone and you don't know when Asus decides it's too old card to get any software support.
Those are at level of ALC889 tested in this comparison.
And ~50£ Sound Blaster Z has two steps better DAC.
(though headphone output is rather standard)

Anyway algorithms processing sound signal to include cues brain uses to process directions are at lest equally important.
(and missing from Realteks)
But as cheap closed design that headset is likely very incapable to any kind binaural sound stage.
Besides directionality there should be good sense of distance to various gun shots in first minute of this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1_20T8x_OI
And especially this is really nice with good binaural sound stage headphones:
https://youtu.be/B8xZp0WPwxs?t=18m51s

So if you want to really get game immersion to good level you would also need capable (as in no gaming trinket) headphones.
With best headphones anything better would basically mean game showing locations of sound sources on map.
And cosed design is huge challenge even for actual audio makers and cheap trinket production gaming garbages are likely at "head in bucket" level in sound stage.

Not sure about other models of Superlux, but Beyerdynamic copying HD330 does extremely well for its price.
Though that's still couple steps below best.
 
Soldato
Joined
7 Mar 2008
Posts
2,614
Location
Kent
What about noise reduction and shielding?

On my current motherboard with the onboard audio, I can here a ton of noise from the rest of the computer, beeps and clicking, hissing and whatever else of the computer working away. I've had to use a sound card just to get rid of this noise(and I can even still sometimes here it slightly through it). How are motherboards for this now, I've seen some of them have shielding but is it any good, and is it for only a few motherboards?
 
Associate
OP
Joined
29 Dec 2005
Posts
145
ALC892 is pretty much bottom of the product barrel codec.
Even Audigy Fx would be clear step higher in D/A conversion quality.
Xonar DGX is technically similar, but has that mediocre Dolby Headphone and you don't know when Asus decides it's too old card to get any software support.
Those are at level of ALC889 tested in this comparison.
And ~50£ Sound Blaster Z has two steps better DAC.
(though headphone output is rather standard)

Anyway algorithms processing sound signal to include cues brain uses to process directions are at lest equally important.
(and missing from Realteks)
But as cheap closed design that headset is likely very incapable to any kind binaural sound stage.
Besides directionality there should be good sense of distance to various gun shots in first minute of this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1_20T8x_OI
And especially this is really nice with good binaural sound stage headphones:
https://youtu.be/B8xZp0WPwxs?t=18m51s

So if you want to really get game immersion to good level you would also need capable (as in no gaming trinket) headphones.
With best headphones anything better would basically mean game showing locations of sound sources on map.
And cosed design is huge challenge even for actual audio makers and cheap trinket production gaming garbages are likely at "head in bucket" level in sound stage.

Not sure about other models of Superlux, but Beyerdynamic copying HD330 does extremely well for its price.
Though that's still couple steps below best.

So basically I need a new sound card and better headset to hear any directionality?
 
Soldato
Joined
6 Jun 2008
Posts
11,616
Location
Finland
So basically I need a new sound card and better headset to hear any directionality?
Certainly wouldn't expect good directionality from cheap closed headphones.
You can use those Youtube videos of my previous post for testing it.
Just disable any effects of Windows/Realtek.
 

V F

V F

Soldato
Joined
13 Aug 2003
Posts
21,184
Location
UK
What about noise reduction and shielding?

On my current motherboard with the onboard audio, I can here a ton of noise from the rest of the computer, beeps and clicking, hissing and whatever else of the computer working away. I've had to use a sound card just to get rid of this noise(and I can even still sometimes here it slightly through it). How are motherboards for this now, I've seen some of them have shielding but is it any good, and is it for only a few motherboards?

You were hearing white noise?
 
Associate
Joined
28 Nov 2012
Posts
668
Are you using the front or rear jack for audio? I've always found the front jack is notoriously bad for picking up electrical noise with on board solutions. I think in most cases the front wiring isn't shielded enough.
 

V F

V F

Soldato
Joined
13 Aug 2003
Posts
21,184
Location
UK
Are you using the front or rear jack for audio? I've always found the front jack is notoriously bad for picking up electrical noise with on board solutions. I think in most cases the front wiring isn't shielded enough.

Doesn't that depend on how it is routed? I know mine goes across the top of the case to the sound card which is well away from power sources in an inverted setup and picks up zero noise.
 
Soldato
Joined
7 Mar 2008
Posts
2,614
Location
Kent
You were hearing white noise?

Nope, not white noise clearly discernible sounds, that are really annoying. I can still even hear them through the sound card if I turn the volume up. Like moving the mouse around the desktop makes a sort of whining noise sometimes. I always use the rear jack.
 
Soldato
Joined
6 Jun 2008
Posts
11,616
Location
Finland
Nope, not white noise clearly discernible sounds, that are really annoying. I can still even hear them through the sound card if I turn the volume up. Like moving the mouse around the desktop makes a sort of whining noise sometimes. I always use the rear jack.
That's pretty common interference of badly implemented integrated.
Separate sound cards avoid those well.
 
Soldato
Joined
19 Jun 2009
Posts
3,852
The best computer audio I've ever had is from a Asus Essence ST, the next closest I've tried is a Creative Titanium HD, but I felt the Essence ST was better.

Regarding noise, even the Essence ST has some noise, however it will be minor compared to motherboard on-board.

To put into perspective the noise from the Asus Essence ST.

Down stairs on the HTPC I have a genuine 120 watt RMS Pioneer 8ohm amp (from the days when 120watt was a proper 120watt), this is feeding 4 x Yamaha NS-F160's at 50 RMS @ 6ohm. If I put the volume on the amp around 60%, and put my head 3 feet away from the speakers I can hear faint background noise from the Asus ST, but bear in mind if music was suddenly playing it would easily be above most normal listening and my head 3 foot away I would eventually have hearing issues! So yes the Asus ST has background noise but you'll only notice it you do tests like I just outlined.

However I don't use the Asus ST on the HTPC, instead I use the DAC that's integrated inside the Pioneer amp. The integrated DAC amp is remarkably close in terms of sound quality to the Asus ST, however it has around 30% of the background noise of the Asus ST.

I will summarize the above below.

Background noise of cheap typical on-board motherboard sound, lets say it's X value.
Background noise Asus ST sound card, lets say about 25% of above X value.
Background noise of external Pioneer Amp/DAC, lets say 30% of above Asus ST.

The lesson here, is if your bothered about background noise, don't even get a sound card, instead just get an external DAC.
 
Soldato
Joined
6 Jun 2008
Posts
11,616
Location
Finland

jcr

jcr

Associate
Joined
29 May 2011
Posts
1,810
Location
southampton
Well impressive figures from the Lynx 22 but that is really professional studio card.

All I really know is my Asus ST is the best card I own, but it has more background noise then the Pioneer DAC/AMP I use.
i have the essence card too and love it. paired up with focal xs speakers it gives lovely sound.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
13 Oct 2006
Posts
90,805
I actually got an offer from Burson a few days ago that they'd send me some samples including the V5i to review but unfortunately I'm way too busy to do them justice at the moment.
 

V F

V F

Soldato
Joined
13 Aug 2003
Posts
21,184
Location
UK
I actually got an offer from Burson a few days ago that they'd send me some samples including the V5i to review but unfortunately I'm way too busy to do them justice at the moment.

There has been interesting comments on them though. Whether they're worth more than a sound card alone I do not know but damn! They're big.

https://www.head-fi.org/threads/bur...-opamps-discussion-and-reviews.854912/page-10

Someone using it with the Auzentech X-Fi Prelude.
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/bur...sion-and-reviews.854912/page-10#post-13986268
 
Back
Top Bottom