Overclocking silently... anyone done it?

Associate
Joined
2 Feb 2012
Posts
440
Hello all,

I like quiet computing - I spend all day (and most of the evening) in an office that has 4 PCs in (3 tower + laptop). I have already successfully built 2 silent/nearly silent PCs which are on 24/7.

The first is an i5-3470S (65W TDP) ESXi server with 460W Silver Power passive PSU, two SSDs and a NoFan CR-95C. When I benchmarked it with prime95 before I installed ESXi, I couldn't get that system more than 30 deg above ambient - even flat out. The PC is entirely passive and has no fans in it at all (and lives in the living room). Silent!

The second is my home server and this runs passively now apart from a couple of fans blowing air over the 8 HDDs at the lowest possible setting of the fan controller. Although it uses an AX760, the fan never comes on and the 95W TDP Athlon II X4 630 is cooled by another NoFan CR-95C which maxes at 78 deg C after 3 days running a CPU stress test. This is all sat in a Fractal Define R3 with all the fan mounts opened to get the most convection. This too is effectively silent (you have to put your ear next to the case to hear the fans blowing air over the HDDs).

I'm just in the process of quietening the last PC which is an overclocked i7-2600K (4.4GHz). I'm moving from an Antec P180 to a Fractal XL R2 (yes, I like Fractal cases!) and I am also installing an AX860 PSU (overkill, but it was cheaper than the 760!!). I currently have a Scythe Ninja cooling the CPU and I get to the low 70's on an overclock. I am running a passive Sapphire 7750 graphics card - I don't game and only got this card as I am running 3 monitors. I am going to see where my temps are with the Ninja+fan and purely convection cooling (and a single 140mm fan wound down as slow as it will go blowing over the few HDDs just to move some air). I would like to change the Scythe for something quieter but would still like to retain the overclock, so I'm thinking of my third NoFan (everything I've read says the NoFan is the best entirely passive cooler) but...

Has anyone actually tried to balance overclocking a Sandy/Ivy with a completely passive heatsink? I'd be willing to move to Ivy (or Haswell when it comes out - in fact the 3 x PCI-e x 16 would help move the graphics card away from the CPU socket too) to keep noise at 0, whilst still retaining a medium overclock.

Thoughts?
 
Overclocking with a completely passive heatsink is asking for trouble :P

Even just an undervolted low spinning fan would be much better than nothing, and remain very quiet.

Have you ever tried water cooling? Although expensive initially, it is a good investment if you want high overclocks while remaining very quiet.
 
ive got a near slient oced pc

4 x fractel fans ~ 19DB
Phanktek cpu cooler running on lowest fan speed

overclocked my i7 3770k to 4.5ghz runs at 55c prime95 undervolted to 1.104

looking to change the fans for more slient solution [phanktek that is]:D

i have a antec P280
 
Overclocking with a completely passive heatsink is asking for trouble :P
Is that from experience or just hearsay? I get the feeling that not many have tried it as most people run graphics cards with fans on, so much of the noise advantage of passive CPU cooling is lost. I'm not looking for the ultimate overclock, just something ~20% better than stock. Given the NoFan and the fact that TDPs are coming back down (yes, I've seen the threads about Ivy heating up more than Sandy), it would seem that a moderate overclock should be achievable...

Everything I've seen about water is that to get high overclocks you need to be running fans quite hard, so isn't very much better when you want it silent. Please bare in mind that I'm currently running the fans cooling the disks in the server at about 300 rpm - behind an acoustically insulated panel. I'm trying to get that sort of level of quiet here!

I guess my other option is an external auto fan controller (I have an Aquero 5 LT) with fans off until the CPU kicks in....
 
As you said water while it can be quiet is not necessarily quiet enough, even passive the pump vibrations can be unwelcome intrusions.


Have you considered a case where you can fit a single high quality sidepanel 200/230mm fan? They can shift a decent amount of air even at v quiet low speeds, and blowing on the the board/cpu give enough airflow to keep a lot of bits cooler.
 
Have you considered a case where you can fit a single high quality sidepanel 200/230mm fan? They can shift a decent amount of air even at v quiet low speeds, and blowing on the the board/cpu give enough airflow to keep a lot of bits cooler.
Not convinced "keeping other bits cooler" is that important TBH. I work for a silicon company, and we expect our devices to be reliable at a junction temperature of 125 deg. C, 24/7 (this is complex consumer electronics). Underneath the skin, all the chips use pretty much the same technology and the mobo (P8P67 at the moment) has reasonable heatsinking in place.

I'm happy enough (i.e. read fairly confident) the case will keep everything within it's designed operating envelope without having to blow air over it... The server seems OK at the moment The only reason I'm blowing air over the disks is to keep them within their operating temps.
 
When web browsing my rig is almost silent, got a fan controller that allows the 6 case fans to be turned off, and the cpu fans are ran via PWM at idle theyre spinning at 400 rpm. Only up the fans on the controller when gaming, the cpu fans speed up automatically. Graphics card is extremely quiet at idle and load using auto fan, though if set manually above 60% speed, it is noticeable.
 
My PC is almost silent too... But it isn't silent.... I now have 2 PCs that are silent. I like this - a lot! I would just like to get this one silent 100% of the time - whilst retaining the overclocking....

Does anyone have any experiences with the NoFan and overclocking? (yes, I could just buy one and try, but I have no plans to build another rig in a while should it not work out but 12 PCs in a household of 3 is probably enough ;))
 
My PC is almost silent too... But it isn't silent.... I now have 2 PCs that are silent. I like this - a lot! I would just like to get this one silent 100% of the time - whilst retaining the overclocking....

Does anyone have any experiences with the NoFan and overclocking? (yes, I could just buy one and try, but I have no plans to build another rig in a while should it not work out but 12 PCs in a household of 3 is probably enough ;))

Nope, but that beast looks like a perfect candidate for a quiet 200/230mm fan!
 
Back
Top Bottom