why are you so anti to head set mics? I find them far superior. Just stop being cheap and get a decent one, people ive heard using desk top ones have always had nasty sound quailty and can hear their game in the background because it has no sound canceling which is just irritating even if they are using push to talk. Also the sound quality of the senhier head sets is also very good considering. But i spent £60 on mine.
Because theres either hassle with the cables or the battery's if wireless ( I'd go with wireless tho, as I absolutely hate cables on headphones).
Then there's voice activation, which is annoying for people living with others like me, if I tell my parents I'm busy or they shout from downstairs all of that gets transmitted so I prefer push to talk.
If you use push to talk anyways, you might as well use speakers, just careful not to transmit when others are talking...
Also, I love 5.1, I use it actively to locate where people are, hate stereo now for anything but music ( for music I just do stereo x2). And since switching between 5.1 speakers and 5.1 headphones is a massive hassle ( as my speakers only have 2.0 headphone out), I just prefer to stick with speakers and only use headphones when my parents moan about the noise.
All of this simply makes me like desktop mics much more, just much less work to get it working or configuring it when you also want/prefer speakers.
