According to AMD my CPU's only 89w, therefore a 170w peltier should be enough, which wouldn't strain the 630w maximum of my PSU even with SLI...
That's 89w AT STOCK. A 170w TEC is a native 24v tec, at 12v it only actually runs as a 120w TEC. Once you overclock your CPU, it's thermal output becomes hyperlinear and it's heat output rapidly grows.
Put it this way, a 226w TEC on a 3200 Clawhammer AT STOCK with voltage raised to 1.7v isn't enough to keep it below +15deg at full load with a triple rad and 50Z pump. Now consider what a 170w TEC operating as a 120w TEC would be capable of. The answer - not worth doing unless you're going all out for 226w or better.
Don't "dabble" with pelts. Do it right, or don't do it.
Apogee
IS compatible with pelts (it's a 5002 series block base reworked, with flow and pins across the entire base - it'll handle pelts fine - s'only the storm that won't), but no option for coldplate clamping, therefore will be hard to achieve suitable clamping force across the TEC, and thus the apogee would be outperformed by much older designed-for-tec-use blocks.
226w on CPU with separate 12v PSU
170w on GPU, run at 120w via 12v of PC PSU
Double or triple rad
D5 or 50Z pump
Maze4-1 blocks or Swiftech MCW50-T (GPU) and MCW5002-T (CPU)