Poll: Poll: MGS2 vs 3 vs 4

[Inazuma]

No idea why (may have something to do with recently getting the soundtracks), but I wanted to know what everyone thinks?

MGS2, 3 and 4 - which had the...

Best levels & gameplay

Best cutscenes

Best soundtrack

Best voice acting

Best boss battles

Best plot

Best cast of characters

Best mullet of Snake

 

[Noel Gallagher]

Only played 2 and 3, well I've played 4 but I don't own it :O

So it's gotta be 2 for all.

 

[Sinny]

MGS1 - aka Tactical espionage, i dont even think the other versions have compared for me, never had a PS2 but played them on my mate's console and did nothing for me.

 

[gt_junkie]

MGS1 - aka Tactical espionage, i dont even think the other versions have compared for me, never had a PS2 but played them on my mate's console and did nothing for me.

Ditto!

Sure there's a bit of 'rose tinted glasses' but IMHO the original was just awesome.

gt

 

[XPE]

3


Subsistence

 

[Inazuma]

I excluded MGS1 for a reason you know

Here's my take

Best levels & gameplay: 4
Best cutscenes: 4
Best soundtrack: 3
Best voice acting: 4
Best boss battles: 3
Best plot: 4
Best cast of characters: 4
Best mullet of Solid Snake: 3

 

[msmalls74]

No idea why (may have something to do with recently getting the soundtracks), but I wanted to know what everyone thinks?

MGS2, 3 and 4 - which had the...

Best levels & gameplay
4
Best cutscenes
4
Best soundtrack
3
Best voice acting
4
Best boss battles
hmm 3 no 2 no 1 er 4? Cant decide ok 3 is my final answer
Best plot
4 (only becasue it tied it all up)
Best cast of characters
4
Best mullet of Solid Snake
4 and the best 'tache

 

[TurnipHead]

Best levels & gameplay : 2
Best cutscenes : 4
Best soundtrack : 3 (only because of Snake Eater)
Best voice acting: 3
Best boss battles: 4
Best plot : 4
Best cast of characters : 4
Best mullet of Solid Snake : 4

 

[Nanoman]

No idea why (may have something to do with recently getting the soundtracks), but I wanted to know what everyone thinks?

MGS2, 3 and 4 - which had the...

Best levels & gameplay
3
Best cutscenes
4
Best soundtrack
3
Best voice acting
4
Best boss battles
4
Best plot
3
Best cast of characters
4
Best mullet of Solid Snake
4

edit. oops MGS1 isnt included.

 

[Sareth]

I excluded MGS1 for a reason you know

Here's my take

How can you answer 3 for the last question ? that doesn't make sense.

 

[Streeteh]

Best levels & gameplay
3

Best cutscenes
4

Best soundtrack
4

Best voice acting
3

Best boss battles
3

Best plot
3

Best cast of characters
3

Best mullet of Solid Snake
4

You git, this thread has made me want to replay MGS4 again (done it 4 times now).

 

[Inazuma]

How can you answer 3 for the last question ? that doesn't make sense.

Yep sorry that was a mistake. I realised it last night while nodding off. The question should just say "Snake"

And lol @ Streeteh

 

[tony888]

i thought the battle with liquid in MGS4 was pretty good

 

[Parsley]

3


Subsistence

This.

 

[Mobius 1]

Best levels & gameplay - 3

Best cutscenes - 4

Best soundtrack - 3!

Best voice acting - 3

Best boss battles - 3/4

Best plot - 4

Best cast of characters - 3

Best mullet of Snake - 2


2 was okay, but didn't really compare to 3 and 4 IMO. 3 was my favorite. i loved the whole soviet setting, it was awesome.

 

[MuGeN]

3 really was the overall don. Its the only one of the series that I just couldn't put down...

 

[pingwing]

The really old top down one on the snes or was it nes..... (os something even more retro that it hurts for me to remember what its called this time of day)

 

[Snapper^]

3rd for me, was simply amazing. Not sure why most people aren't keen on it, 4 was awesome to tho

 

[Senture]

3 for me, I really really hate 4

 

[Scort]

I don't recall the others well enough to be honest, I played 1 when it first came out on PS, then again on PC, but only played 2 and 3 a few years back.

For me though, 4 wiped the floor with all of them, so it gets my vote.

Scort.