I doubt there will be 100W difference and here's why.
At the low power (idle) end where the efficiencies will vary more between supplies, you're not drawing much power anyway, so even a huge difference still isn't much.
At the higher end you'll be in the flatter area of efficiencies which might be, say, 10% different as an example. Even pulling 500W, that's only a 50W difference in power draw.
Also, thee's no telling which one will draw more, I suspect that the 1000W supply will actually be more efficient, they generally need to be due to heat.