Quietest case?

Associate
Joined
4 Dec 2007
Posts
322
Hey all,

I'm trying to spec a PC for my friend, but he really wants a silent PC, he seems to be really particular on the noise lol. Which are the good cases out there which are the quietest?

Also i presume a quiet CPU cooler would be needed too right...
 
Last edited:
Get a fanless cpu cool the thermalright ones are good, in regards to case, it's not the case that really quiet it's what's inside it, if you get a heatsink on the gpu that will reduce noise levels and HDD anti-vibrators that should make for "silent" pc.
 
If wants silence then he should look at steel-case (Antec, Coolermaster) because less prone to rattling panels, etc. He might also have to change the case fans to achieve his goal.

What's spec does he plans to put inside it, i.e. CPU, GFX, etc?
 
Well the thing is, I don't think he is going to build the PC himself, so either he was looking for a pre-built system here or use the PC builder...which makes things more tricky and limited i guess case wise :)

Hes actually bought this system last week:

"Titan Accelerator" Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 2.40GHz @ 3.00GHz+ DDR2 System"
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showp...e 2 Quad Q6600 2.40GHz @ 3.00GHz+ DDR2 System

(With Coolermaster RC-1000 case)

and was telling me today its loud :P

So i was trying to list him some cases which are quiet...and was saying it has a lot to do with the CPU fan too.
 
Last edited:
Does he mean silent or just very quiet.

Does he mean silent or just very quiet - they are different.
Silent and overclocked quad, gaming pc don't really go together ;)

Can be done but not with air cooling.

A quiet pc is acheivable with new case fans and swapping the AC Freezer one of the better tower coolers (so that it's fan can run at a slower speed)

Aftermarket cooler on that Graphics card is a must!

May also need to swap the psu - don't know much about the OCZ one interms of fan noise.
The enermax 82+ and Corsair HX are both excerlant modular psu - save you a few quid on running costs and neaten the case to improve airflow.

Edit: has he tried turning down the case fan?
 
Last edited:
For a start the GPU fan will wayyyy outweigh any noise reduced by quieter fans unless you fit an aftermarket heatsink
 
Play about with the things in his current setup - replace GPU cooler and turn the case fans / cpu fan down.
 
Cosmos is about quietest design case of Coolermaster so that's decent starting point. (but stock fans probably aren't that great)

CPU is hot compared to modern Intels but nothing which can't be handled by high end heatsinks designed for Netbursts and AMD's top models. (that AC isn't such)
Seagates haven't been among quietest drives since PATA drives.
And those tiny single slot graphic card coolers are probably noisy when crammed to cards with heat output double of that point where exhausting dual slot cooler would become sensible.


If wants silence then he should look at steel-case (Antec, Coolermaster) because less prone to rattling panels, etc.
Steel won't help much more against vibration. (unless it's real steel = 5+ mm)
Better to try to decouple HDD mechanically from case and to select quiet parts to start with.
 
Steel won't help much more against vibration. (unless it's real steel = 5+ mm)
Better to try to decouple HDD mechanically from case and to select quiet parts to start with.

Completely agree with second point but there are two quite different approaches to very quiet setups.

Silent aluminum case work best when hard fixed to components so the case acts as an extra heatsink - therefore reducing the 'need' for fans.
They can 'rattle' especially if all the fans are running at same reverberance as one of the panels, but many people have no problems.

Silent steel cases rely on weight and isolation to deal with noise.
They should have a solid frame with gromits/spacers between it and everything ideally

If you are going to decupple your HHD / opticals / PSU there is very little point in an aluminum case (usless it looks good) as your working agained it's passive design.
 
Last edited:
I've never seen or heard a noisy case. They're all silent. To build a quiet PC, you have to start from the basis that you are going to pick quiet components.

1. Passive or semi passive CPU cooler. A Thermalright HR-01 with the duct will quite happily cool an E5200 or E8400 with a low VID. So will a Zalman reserator. A Q6600 is going to require serious investment to cool passively and quietly.

2. Passive graphics card cooler. Artctic Cooling make a fully passive solution for almost any graphics card, so that makes sense to me.

3. Quiet HDD. Samsung make good, quiet HDD. It does make a difference.

4. Optical drives - Laptop optical drives are really the only option here.

5. Reduce the number of fans to an absolute minimum. If you have more than 2, you're doing something wrong or you're seriously oveclocked.

6. It's going to run hot, so you need to cool the room down.

Even if you have a soundproofed case like a Lian Li S80 it won't quieten down noisy components.

It sounds to me like your friend bought a download PC for his bedroom and now he can't sleep while he downloads all those torrents. What a pity.;)
 
Steel won't help much more against vibration. (unless it's real steel = 5+ mm)
Coming from a (steel) Coolermaster to (aluminum) Lian-Li I find the latter more prone to rattling & has to be cleaned regularly.

That said, currently running my quietest set-up ever & thanks to the Lian-Li's material, helps in keeping temps low.
 
I've never seen or heard a noisy case. They're all silent.
Even if you have a soundproofed case like a Lian Li S80 it won't quieten down noisy components.

2. Passive graphics card cooler. Artctic Cooling make a fully passive solution for almost any graphics card, so that makes sense to me.

3. Quiet HDD. Samsung make good, quiet HDD. It does make a difference.
Sure nothing makes noisy components quiet and case itself doesn't produce noise but noisy design case leaks slightest noises directly out and lack of good HDD soft mounting often means whole case acts as loudspeaker.

2: Those look 100% good on paper but in real life they have one serious downside: They leave all heat inside case meaning CPU needs better cooling and you have to increase exhaust from that area.

3: And SPCR has often recommended soft mounting them and double recommended that for some Samsungs. (latest seem again better)
If top performance isn't needed WD Caviar Green/GP drives should be clear number one choise also because of notably lower heat output.
 
Get a case like the Nzxt whisper it is very very quiet.
Sure it's quieter than fashionable thousand and one holes magpie nests but that design has also deficiencies.
1. Front. There's no real door allowing noise of intake fan and HDDs to leak out directly.
2. Side panels. Only foam and no heavy mass loading layer. (for real life example dense heavy wall blocks also airborne noise better than light wall)
3. Pair of 80mm fans? Living in last millennium?

Easy to fix parts are meshes in front of back fans and that bling intake fan made of often resonating clear plastic.

Coming from a (steel) Coolermaster to (aluminum) Lian-Li I find the latter more prone to rattling & has to be cleaned regularly.
While it's definitely very easy to notice "better" vibration ability of lighter aluminum weight of steel isn't enough: I once had second hand Chieftec's heavy maxi tower and side panels had about 4mm of bitumen mat for additional weight and vibration of hard mounted HDDs was still easily noticeable by touching side panel so heavier materials alone just don't cut it...
And damping material is still needed resulting really high empty weight for already heavy case.

As example I've been working on with Lian Li A71 and at default it sounded quite bad when tapping some part by finger. It's mostly done and I've been slowly going over smaller parts tapping it now results only muffled sound and weight is still only ~11,5kg which is fair 2kg lighter than undamped empty weight of previous case (CM Stacker) which already had aluminum side panels. With damping mats that case weighted ~17kg and because of rather noisy design getting it really quiet would have required using very quiet components and lowering fan speeds to very low!
I'll be still adding some damping mat to few areas for keeping down possible vibration from things like optical drives but no doubt weight of this case will stay about 5kg lower and because of much quieter design I don't have any doubts it will be quieter without sacrifices in performance of parts.

Need for cleaning/wiping is all about surface finish/paint, not material.
White shows dirt and dust well but also black shows dust and black is even worse for fingerprints. Also any kind glossiness makes fingerprints more visible. That good old boring beige was actually very good at hiding fingerprints. Also dark blue of that above Chieftec was quite good in that aspect.
 
I gotta agree some great ideas/comments here, I have had my PC 1 meter away from my head while I sleep since my PC is on 24/7 and there are far too many factors that cause the noise.

I agree with WJA96 its whats inside that counts, if your gonna aim for a silent/quiet PC you may have to grin and bear some hot PC its the price you ultimately pay.

Passive is the way too go, in fact for my next PC I was just considering a Semi/Passive PSU or high efficiency 80-90% p/s that way it doesn't get hot or have to work its fan much, and a Large Passive Heatsink or that Heatsink with a 140mm Super silent fan where the blade barely turns... ill defiantly consider a thermalright passive heatsink for the graphics card again with a silent 120mm fan of course.

I am however considering 1TB Green WD power efficient hdds that run like 40% less power then the normal drives and they still are luke warm to the touch, I have one but yeah can still hear the read/write access so ill consider putting them inside Japanese Gup Silent boxes that way I cant hear it at all !

I aint decided on a Case but have mixed feelings perhaps was considering a Case with just one giant 200mm silent Case fan and then no fans at all on the inside ?

Watercooling was another thought too !
 
Get a cheap alimunium case, like the Antec 300 or 1200. Having a side panel without a fan hole will also help noise levels.

Sure you can use many fans, but that isnt the problem - its their individual speed which makes the noise.

You can get some normal fans and volt mod them that will quieten them down a lot. The bigger the fan is the more air it can shift at a lower speed and therefore lower noise level. Also bigger fans produce a lower frequency noise, small fans make a high pitched noise, so try and only get 120mm+ fans.

If you put a fan in and volt mod it it might produce ~16db or so which is quite quiet (not silent, but good enough), but then if you add another one its not 16 + 16, thats not how the db scale works. It will probably add 2-3 db on top of the original 16db. So dont be afraid of having 3 case fans if its much better than 2.

Use an aftermarket cooler on the GPU as it will be louder than all your volt modded fans put together.

Buy quiet hard drives, and if they are still too loud, do the bungee mod and suspend them with some knitting elastic.

Or if he really wants a quiet PC, tell him to get a decent quiet laptop.
 
Back
Top Bottom