Ok so this is shamefully ripped off from the man utd forum but basically list your first team squad and rate them from 1-10
Mine:
Goalies:
VDS - 8 - Doesn't get a 9 because of his age you never know with injuries, so far though that doesn't seem to have effected him
PIG - 7 - Better than most reserve keepers
Fullbacks:
Rafael - 8 - Potentially world class
Evra - 10 - Best LB in the world (arguably)
O'shea - 7 - Very useful squad player
Neville - 6 - Not that bad in a last resort kind of situation
Fabio - 6 - Never fit, cant pass judgement
Centrehalves:
Rio - 7 - NEVER fit
Vidic - 10 - One of the best in the world
Evans - 8 - Cant see how anyone can question his ability
Smalling - 7 - Haven't seen any of our pre-season games but by all accounts is already capable
Brown - 5 - A liability at CB now IMO
Midfield:
Fletcher - 9 - Will never be highly thought of outside of the club but as important to us as Lampard, Gerrard & Fabregas are to their respective clubs
Carrick - 8 - Has to get back on form following last season, nothing to say he wont
Anderson - 5 - Surprised he's still at the club to be honest, this could be his last
Gibson - 7 - Still has it all to prove but his goal scoring is something every other midfielder lacks at the moment
Scholes - 7 - When he's good he's still outstanding, when he's not he's dire
Giggs - 8 - See above but to a lesser extent
Park - 7 - I think centrally in a 3 has to be his position from now on. Very useful member of the squad
Nani - 8 - Potentially world class, needs to prove it on a regular basis though
Valencia - 9 - Outstanding wide player, from his 1 pre season game so far it seems he wont have a problem reproducing last seasons form
Cleverly - 6 - Doubt he'll get games tbh
Attackers:
Rooney - 10 - No brainer
Berbatov - 5 - Simply not a goal threat
Owen - 7 - Very useful member of the squad
Hernandez - 7 - Probably too soon to really say, promising signs though
Macheda - 6 - Needs to show his goal scoring ability in the Carling Cup this season to really push on
Mine:
Goalies:
VDS - 8 - Doesn't get a 9 because of his age you never know with injuries, so far though that doesn't seem to have effected him
PIG - 7 - Better than most reserve keepers
Fullbacks:
Rafael - 8 - Potentially world class
Evra - 10 - Best LB in the world (arguably)
O'shea - 7 - Very useful squad player
Neville - 6 - Not that bad in a last resort kind of situation
Fabio - 6 - Never fit, cant pass judgement
Centrehalves:
Rio - 7 - NEVER fit
Vidic - 10 - One of the best in the world
Evans - 8 - Cant see how anyone can question his ability
Smalling - 7 - Haven't seen any of our pre-season games but by all accounts is already capable
Brown - 5 - A liability at CB now IMO
Midfield:
Fletcher - 9 - Will never be highly thought of outside of the club but as important to us as Lampard, Gerrard & Fabregas are to their respective clubs
Carrick - 8 - Has to get back on form following last season, nothing to say he wont
Anderson - 5 - Surprised he's still at the club to be honest, this could be his last
Gibson - 7 - Still has it all to prove but his goal scoring is something every other midfielder lacks at the moment
Scholes - 7 - When he's good he's still outstanding, when he's not he's dire
Giggs - 8 - See above but to a lesser extent
Park - 7 - I think centrally in a 3 has to be his position from now on. Very useful member of the squad
Nani - 8 - Potentially world class, needs to prove it on a regular basis though
Valencia - 9 - Outstanding wide player, from his 1 pre season game so far it seems he wont have a problem reproducing last seasons form
Cleverly - 6 - Doubt he'll get games tbh
Attackers:
Rooney - 10 - No brainer
Berbatov - 5 - Simply not a goal threat
Owen - 7 - Very useful member of the squad
Hernandez - 7 - Probably too soon to really say, promising signs though
Macheda - 6 - Needs to show his goal scoring ability in the Carling Cup this season to really push on
