Regarding exercising properly: toning and cardio routine for mid-section

Associate
Joined
23 Mar 2006
Posts
906
Location
Guildford, Surrey
So I'd like to put to all you fitness buffs a couple of questions I've got.

I've been running now for the best part of 2 years. Typically I'll run about 3 miles a day for 5 days a week on certain days, usually about 2 a week; I'll combine this with a weight training exercise using dumbbells. The dumbbells are only about 7kg each and the exercises are more for toning and control, on arms and chest. I don't think I've broken beyond this point because I'm somewhat lacking in core strength and endurance. This is somewhat evidenced by the fact that whilst I am well-toned and muscular going up to my waist and across my chest and arms, I've still got a flabby tummy and lower back.

To rectify this, I've acquired an exercise ball and been shown a good variety of mid-section exercises to build on core strength and encourage muscle definition in the abs and lower back.

I've tried to expand on these exercises and also find the best way to incorporate a routine that involves these exercises and my running as a form of cardio.

I've come across two problems.

Because I'm specifically focusing on abs now, the internet is literally teeming with rubbish and spam about "getting a flat stomach" which is clearly designed to rope in the fatties. You'll never find the same advice replicates itself. There are numerous videos on YouTube which involve personal trainers going through exercise ball routines, but many of them seem to contradict each other because there are simply so many of them. I'm after a good routine for core (abs and lower back) involving the exercise ball and/or dumbbells I can replicate 2-3 times a week.

I've also been trying to work out if it's best to start a routine with toning exercises and move on to running to finish, or vice versa: I would like to devise a routine where I benefit from my running in the sense that by performing core strength and toning exercises I'm opening up to allow my cardio element to burn the fat around my mid-section in a targeted manner. Again, sifting through the nonsense on the internet, I've not been able to find a straight answer on this one.

My run takes about 20 minutes and I don't think I need to spend more than 20 minutes on toning exercises to see some good results and build up some core strength. I think this is a reasonable expectation that I should get something out of 40 minutes of exercise but I wonder if my expectations are too high.

I realise it's a bit silly asking on a forum like this about exercise, but I've tried a few fitness forums and most of the answers are contradictory and seem to be from spambots and sellers of some kind. I'm sure there are some folks on here that'll have the knowledge I need to start burning some belly fat. :o
 
Firstly, doing ab works won't get rid of your flabby stomach. You can't spot reduce fat. It appears you are still carrying some fat on you which you will need to shift in order to have the flat look.

Secondly, 'toning' is really another way of saying 'losing fat and putting on some muscle'. Lifting 7kg weights is only going to get you so far, you really need to be progressively increasing the weight to stimulate growth.

Lastly, you're better off doing a more overall workout rather than focusing on a small amount of muscles. If you focus too much on 1 muscle area you can create imbalances which will cause you some problems.

Dons - please move this to sports section.
 
Last edited:
If you want more definition then lose body fat, increase the run distance 5% a week.

If you wish to improve your core strength then take up yoga, or pilates. If you want abs and good muscle definition then lose weight, once you get into low teens/single digit body fat then you start to get great definition.

EDIT:

In fact, you'd be better off taking up a sport that will condition you well and give you a decent structured training program. I suggest, as always, rowing.
 
Take that 7kg, strap it to your chest, do 3 sets 10-15 reps of sit ups 3 x a week

Combine that with a general workout and you'll start to see changes in 4-8 weeks.
 
Take that 7kg, strap it to your chest, do 3 sets 10-15 reps of sit ups 3 x a week

Combine that with a general workout and you'll start to see changes in 4-8 weeks.

So with regards to the swiss ball and abs wheel I've just got, there's nothing useful i can do with these?!

I should add i've been doing sit ups for months now (albeit, incorrectly as they've procured no results)
 
You need to lose fat from your stomach or you'll see no improvement in definition.
 
You need to lose fat from your stomach or you'll see no improvement in definition.

yes but my effective question was, if i combine a routine that involves my running and toning exercises using a ball and wheel, will i actually see some weight loss? I wanted to know if i could make it more effective by say for example, going for a run first then having a toning workout, will that in essence speed up the burning process?
 
You're diet is just as if not more important than your training.

Bowl of cereal, two pieces of fruit, a sandwich, a yoghurt, main meal.

throughout the day tea/coffee with no sugar, water, squash.

Don't think it's particularly mental?
 
Bowl of cereal, two pieces of fruit, a sandwich, a yoghurt, main meal.

throughout the day tea/coffee with no sugar, water, squash.

Don't think it's particularly mental?

That means nothing tbh. Go find a kcal calculator and figure out how much you are consuming, be honest about it. then look at a calculator to see how many kcal you should be consuming to lose weight.
 
That means nothing tbh. Go find a kcal calculator and figure out how much you are consuming, be honest about it. then look at a calculator to see how many kcal you should be consuming to lose weight.

Well I was honest about it, comes to about 1496 - 1896 a day.
 
Well I was honest about it, comes to about 1496 - 1896 a day.

so say 1700kcal a day you are taking in. Now workout how much you are burning and you have the basis of working out how much you will lose a week/month/year
 
so say 1700kcal a day you are taking in. Now workout how much you are burning and you have the basis of working out how much you will lose a week/month/year

well i'm 6ft4 and i run for about 20-25 minutes daily 5 days a week.
I also incorporate 20 minutes of other workout, either weights or toning exercises 2-3 times a week, although I could probably work on making it more controlled.
 
If you are holding fat on your stomach and lower back it could be due to the amount of carbs you are taking in, maybe try replacing them with some protein and fat and see how it goes.
 
couple of questions, what do you weigh and do you drink at all, as i know a few runners who have a gut on them because they just cant keep away from a few pints after work.

but id ditch the ball and stuff and look at a more rounded work out rather than aiming just as the core as you will see gains faster as well as get overall stronger and fitter.
 
I weigh 14kg and I'm not technically overweight, I have a good BMI.

I drink occasionally, probably once a fortnight at most. I'm driver most of the time and live out in the sticks so i don't really do alcohol on anything more than once fortnightly and that's being generous.

I'd rather just aim at my core. Running seems to be doing what i want for my legs and the core is the only part of my body that isn't in good shape and i've been at overall exercises for two years seeing no improvement and i'm getting kinda sick of it tbh..
 
Back
Top Bottom