Sharing Internet via switch/powerline for gaming

Associate
Joined
24 Mar 2023
Posts
4
Location
Uk
Hi
A few months ago i built my two sons basic gaming pcs from new parts. Identical machines, ordered two of everything and setup in exactly the same way.

They share a bedroom and sit next to each other. Rather than buy wifi adapters for the two pcs i bought a Netgear GS105ev2 switch, have the two pcs connected to the switch and the switch connected to a powerline adapter.

The second adapter is obviously downstairs and plugged into the router.

The switch is setup as factory setup out of the box.

When the pcs are on if i do a speed test this happens;
pc1 it'll hit 70Mbps DL and 16Mbps UL. pc2 not running test.
pc2 it'll hit 70Mbps DL and 16Mbps UL. pc1 not running test.

Both pcs show the same IP during the test, i assume due to the switch.

If i run a test at the same time, one hogs the bandwidth, say 65Mbps and the other 5Mbps DL and 15Mbps and 1Mbps UL.
It seems which ever actually starts the test first, gets the band width.

Is this normal?

And is there a better way to set them up. I can't plug them in directly into the router but would it be better to have two powerline adapters or is the switch more efficient?
OR, is a decent wifi adapter just as good? (PCI-E type, not usb).

Much appreciate any comments.
 
Thankyou for the speedy response.

My broadband is with talktalk and is fibre65. i think its fibre to the box at the end of my street then standard cable to the house. Its supposed to run a minimum of 59Mbps but is spec'd at 65Mbps. Doing the odd test i often see speeds of 73 but i think this is possibly due to being close to the box, or the platform they sell has had an upgrade of capability and they have just not updated its name!

I know I'm achieving around the performance values I'm supposed to be receiving as I've stated above. I was more concerned with the traffic shaping part of it.

If its not broke i wont fix it. I'm sure if i swapped to wifi i'll just get a different set of issues and trust the wired connection to be more robust overall.

Thanks again.
 
Virgin have literally just finished putting fibre into our street. Left a right mess, but should be going live very soon. I'll let a few neighbours get the ball rolling then might change over to that. Looking online it looks quite competitively priced.
 
Back
Top Bottom