tbh I'd argue that they're not as good as Skate 3 (or especially 2, minus dark flips/handplants), and on a technical level not as good as Session or SkaterXL (although part of that may be that I'm taking a while to get used to the control scheme again)
I agree with most of your negatives, I was especially disaapointed with the video editor - no ability as far as I can tell to cut between different camera modes (like having multiple 'tripod' centres for a clip)