SNMP Monitoring

Associate
Joined
3 Oct 2007
Posts
795
I have been asked to put in requests for monies for projects in the next financial year.

As the newly 'promoted' server manager we are sorely missing a system to alert the team when something has gone wrong, not when the calls flood the helpdesk.

I am looking to monitor our 100 or so servers (Mostly HP with some IBM and Dell), Cisco core switches and WAN links.

I know from reading this forum, that there are a number of people who manage far more servers than I, so I am interested what people use/have used and your opinions.

regards,

Little_Crow
 
Have a look at HP SIM (Systems Insight Manager). We use it for monitoring our servers and UPS. You can import MIBs to support other devices, though there are a lot supported by default. We have managed Dell before as well.
 
Solarwinds Orion will do servers/wan links/routers etc etc, as will it's smaller cousing IPMonitor.

Both will give you gateway bandwidth utilisation (if the device has the mib's for this), server alerting, service alerts etc via snmp. Also netflow with Orion, if you purchase the module for this.
 
A vote for HP Openview here.

Also ensure that you use SNMP v3 if you implement monitoring within your existing network (so the traffic is encrypted) or fork out the traffic onto another dedicated network VLAN (in an ideal world do both).

Don't want people gathering intelligence from snooping ;)
 
We did have Openview on a PC quite some time ago (2-3 years), before I took this job, but it fell into disuse.
I had little to do with it, but it struck me as being hideously complicated for what you got out of it, but I'll take another look.

We are looking for a dashboard displaying a list of Servers\Switches with traffic lights indicating the status.
Then a click on the server to give you a more detailed view of it's status.

The plan is to have a nice big screen in the infrastructure team office, and another in the helpdesk for constant monitoring and early warning.


Thanks for all your suggestions so far.
 
Ill drop in another vote for Cacti, excellent for trending of any SNMP capable device, support is very good and additonal modules are released frequently, unfortunately it doesnt proactively alert the operator if a node is down.

We use it in combination with Solarwinds Orion and the Enterprise Console which for the price is very feature rich and well supported. I will agree that products such as HP Openview and Ciscoworks are excellent but only realy come into there element when monitoring there own vendor specific equipment.
 
We use it in combination with Solarwinds Orion and the Enterprise Console which for the price is very feature rich and well supported. I will agree that products such as HP Openview and Ciscoworks are excellent but only realy come into there element when monitoring there own vendor specific equipment.

With regard to OpenView;

The problem with OpenView is that an out of the box implementation will do sweet FA. OpenView will manage devices from any vendor in 99% of cases.

Additionally. OpenView is a brand name for a wide range of HP Enterprise Software products (and following the mercury acquisition all HP enterprise apps must drop the OpenView prefix) and does not refer to one particular piece of Software.
Common pieces of OpenView Enterprise Management software are:
- HP OpenView Network Node Manager: In its latest release is now known as NNMi
- HP OpenView Operations Manager for Windows\Unix - Now known as OMU (Ops Manager for Unix) and OMW (Ops Manager for Windows)

Subcomponents of these are performance management tools, reporting tools, messaging tools, and smart plug-ins to manage everything from ESX to rickety old Tru64 Boxes (nearly all stuff is catered for).

These enterprise management products are simply a framework to enable you to build your own monitoring solution. They require reading of a phenominal amount of concept guides and whitepapers but can pay off incredibly well. I administer an Operations Manager for Unix install, it provides service dashboards, a trouble ticket interface into multiple service desks, report generation, sla monitoring and server management/monitoring. The application allows you to install "agents" on almost any OS platform (as well as snmp for stuff like SANS, Aircon units, Tape Units, UPS's etc), these agents then talk back to the central management server via HTTPs. Through these agents you can then execute scripts and applications, browse things such as WMI, look and test for almost any condition and read any logfiles etc. This information is then turned into an alert, or stored in the DB as a performance metric, or promoted into a trouble ticket. You can also run automatic commands based on the conditions you find, such as restarting a service, deleting the temporary files, kicking idle users off terminal service etc.

Its a very powerful system and can massively reduce the need for a big Ops team when managing large estates. Quite expensive though, agent licences are tiered to sockets, OMU requires Oracle (most products can run on x86 windows iron with whatever DB you like), for example the install I administer requires two HP SuperDomes to manage round 2000 servers and a thousand SNMP devices. An additional 4-Way SQL box is used for Reporting.

A lot of companies can find Network Node Manager or Operations Manager on a shelf somewhere - even if its 10 years old, reactivation of support will get you the latest version - though any increase in licence capacity would obviously have to be factored in. It does require a large amount of effort to get it to go beyond the basics, but worth it if you've gone to the expense of buying it!
 
Last edited:
Used quite a few. Zenoss is great for free but has the odd bug. Good forums though and you can pay for commercial support if needed. The Google Maps Mashup dashboard looks impressive too :)
 
Tried out a few of the suggestions here, we've only given them a days test each:

Zenoss (Free) was OK, but to get a trial for the enterprise edition was a nightmare so immediately disqualified itself.

Systems Insight Manager was pretty good.

Castlerock: looks like a very powerful product, but poor dashboard.

We have also tried:

Opmanager: 2nd best so far, pretty dashboard for the helpdesk peeps and plenty of extra information available for the infrastructure team.

Whatsup gold: The best yet, excellent dashboard for showing up problems and lots of extra information available for identifying trends etc. Also the easiest to setup and configure.

We still have to try Solarwinds Orion, and then pick the best 2 for further in-depth testing.

Cheers for all your suggestions.
 
Back
Top Bottom