So I came up with a way to defeat adblock...

Soldato
Joined
12 Jan 2004
Posts
3,172
Location
Brighton
Completely, unequivocally and finally. I wasn't looking for it particularly, I use adblock all the time, but basically if you installed this piece of software on your server, its game over for adblock.

So, the question is, what do I do with the idea? I'm not usually a man for money, but if I open up and tell everyone the idea, (which I have pretty much confirmed works), then all the companies will start using it, and people like "us" don't benefit any more. So, 2 questions :

a) If a lame-o like me can think of it, anyone can. That means, it uses only standard web technologies. If anyone can think of it, it means it is inevitable.

b) If it is inevitable, then I might as well make some cash from these companies before everyone knows about it and adblock becomes totally useless. But does it make me scum to make money from something like this? There are no benefits to open source if I just publish it, I might as well tax the people who would benefit.

Of course, the biggest dilemna is that of course, everyone will get spammed with adverts all over again... including me. I thought of implementing a white list in it, either by IP or something, to not show adverts to those people but then, how do you decide who sees them and who doesn't?

/discuss
 
Well, it isn't using javascript, server side stuff only, basically just beating the idea of a "blacklist".

Had a further thought and it would probably require design / implementation of apache/iis modules to fulfill the functionality, and I can't be bothered to implement it - rememeber, some large 50% of an idea is implementation, not just design. Even if the idea worked, if it caned the servers then it is useless.

Thing is, if I explain it here, aren't I just going to free up the idea? As in, companies will use it? I don't want adblock dead just yet...

(PS those websites that put the text behind the ad, just put text behind the ad, they don't actually detect that you have adblock. And if you try to use your own server with a cache, you can just regex the cache. The trick is to defeat regex blacklists permanently.)
 
Back
Top Bottom