Spec me a Kodi/HTPC box

Soldato
Joined
20 Nov 2006
Posts
6,881
Lads,

Looking for a media solution. So many out there that I just don't know which one to settle with any more. Been considering the brix, beebox, NUC etc to give you an idea. Would like to install windows OS and KODI.

Please share any advise, Budget approx. £250.

Thanks in advance.
 
Knock up a cheap i3 build, biggest outlay is for HDD's for data storage if you dont have a NAS.
Or just put together something out of old parts and run openelec (I'm using an old AMD AM2 chip with 2 gig of ram, runs fine)
 
Indeed Nuc as anything you spec will be louder. Can even get a fanless case for zero moving parts.

Do you need windows? Openelec will give you kodi.
 
Id say NUC is my number 1 choice right now but so many different build options I didn't know what model to go for. Windows would be handy for net browsing and downloading torrents straight to USB hard drive.
 
Last edited:
With respect to the above answers they all miss the obvious question, what exactly do you want to do? Is it stream content from local storage on the box/a local server/nas or are you streaming from sites that would benefit from running a VPN to bypass ISP level blocking or services that require specific things to function e.g. silverlight. For your budget do you need windows and do you need local storage?

If it's a local streamer then a pi2 is a decent shout, at a push it'll deal with a VPN and remote streaming, but it's not ideal so an atom based box at £20-30 more and a Cherry Trail with 4k support comes in at just under £100 would make more sense. The atom is a better bet than the Pi2 as it has the power to run AUO (SAB+CouchPotato+SSickBeard)/rtorrent/chromium on openelec though don't expect to do unRAR+PAR repairs while watching etc. without seriously limiting core usage. If you want an all in one download box then consider an i3 as the extra grunt and option of more RAM (atom has a 2gb limit).

Personally I run a few different boxes, a pi and pi2, an old ION based Revo 3610, a Z3735 based win8 tablet, an i3 NUC and an i3 windows based HTPC. The Revo and NUC run OE and a mix of playback from the local server and online streaming services, the Pi's run OE with access to local server content (kids rooms). The i3 NUC runs a VPN connection for privacy and bypassing ISP level blocking, the windows based HTPC is (or rather was) mainly a download box. I used focus **** to make it boot kodi on startup and keep it to the front screen. I combined this with a flirc and bound koi to the green button (seemed fitting for xbmc as was), this let my Sky remote control my TV, Sky box and HTPC. In hind sight I could do the same with OE now and it would work better, i'd just need a local scratch disk for downloads till they could be moved to network storage.
 
Also worth pointing out that the Pi couldn't cope with the size of my library (ooer missus), and I doubt it's considered massive.
 
With respect to the above answers they all miss the obvious question, what exactly do you want to do? Is it stream content from local storage on the box/a local server/nas or are you streaming from sites that would benefit from running a VPN to bypass ISP level blocking or services that require specific things to function e.g. silverlight. For your budget do you need windows and do you need local storage?

If it's a local streamer then a pi2 is a decent shout, at a push it'll deal with a VPN and remote streaming, but it's not ideal so an atom based box at £20-30 more and a Cherry Trail with 4k support comes in at just under £100 would make more sense. The atom is a better bet than the Pi2 as it has the power to run AUO (SAB+CouchPotato+SSickBeard)/rtorrent/chromium on openelec though don't expect to do unRAR+PAR repairs while watching etc. without seriously limiting core usage. If you want an all in one download box then consider an i3 as the extra grunt and option of more RAM (atom has a 2gb limit).

Personally I run a few different boxes, a pi and pi2, an old ION based Revo 3610, a Z3735 based win8 tablet, an i3 NUC and an i3 windows based HTPC. The Revo and NUC run OE and a mix of playback from the local server and online streaming services, the Pi's run OE with access to local server content (kids rooms). The i3 NUC runs a VPN connection for privacy and bypassing ISP level blocking, the windows based HTPC is (or rather was) mainly a download box. I used focus **** to make it boot kodi on startup and keep it to the front screen. I combined this with a flirc and bound koi to the green button (seemed fitting for xbmc as was), this let my Sky remote control my TV, Sky box and HTPC. In hind sight I could do the same with OE now and it would work better, i'd just need a local scratch disk for downloads till they could be moved to network storage.

Talk about over complicating the issue.
Its pretty obvious what he wants - he even typed it into his post.

As others have said a NUC seems like your best option for budget.
 
Talk about over complicating the issue.
Its pretty obvious what he wants - he even typed it into his post.

As others have said a NUC seems like your best option for budget.

On the contrary, I read the OP's posts and the spec and requirements are vague, or at least need clarification and here's why:

Minimum spec that does what he says he wants is a £59, that will buy you a Z3735 2GB/32GB atom stick including 100% legal Windows 8/10, coincidentally a windows licence for a NUC costs the same. HOWEVER if he wants to add other things later such as SABnzbd,CP/SB and a VPN or do encoding direct from the box, or has specific client software he needs to run for a paid service for example then a 2GB atom stick is not ideal, he'd be better with something else.

2820 NUC £110
120GB SSD £40
4GB RAM £20
Windows £59

Total £229

i3 NUC £220
4GB £20
120GB SSD £40

Total £280

Z3735 T02 £59
2Gb RAM
32GB SSD
Win 8/10

Total £59

The Z3735 based atom will usually match or outperform the 2820 in all but single core benchmarks, it's ideal for situations where you playback from a network resource or local storage and/or streaming from online, can handle torrenting with ease along with running a VPN. Where it would fall over and the 2820/i3 would win is if he has any wish to download from newsgroups and do any PAR repairs, trans-coding or encoding as the 2820 will take up to 8gb or RAM and conventional SSD's/HD's.

That's why asking the question is important, if you take his requirements at face value a NUC makes little sense, by understanding his needs/wants and what he might need/want in the future it may be more sensible to try and fit an i3/OpenElec build into his budget (i5 is only £25ish more), that said if he just wants to use an existing USB drive and do exactly what he says he could save £170 now to go towards what he wants later on as his needs grow.
 
Last edited:
I personally don't trust most things that are imported from China.

Not many decent reviews on Amazon, either.
http://www.amazon.com/Meegopad-Windows-Upgraded-Computer-Bluetooth/dp/B00S6LJVR8

Does it support DTS, DTS-HD and other decent audio formats? Or compressed DD only?

China make (at least at an OEM level) most of the tech we use/buy. Intel do the compute stick for £99 if you prefer intel's QC but it's still from China.

The audio question is an interesting one, in the case of the stick's as they are designed with wifi in mind and streaming DTS-HD MA or TrueHD over Wifi won't usually end well, so it's a slightly moot point. Ignoring that for a moment it'll do PCM across the board, but not pass through of MA/THD. If we talk NUC then in windows you're not in for an easy ride with the 2820 until you update to drivers from this year onward under windows, but OpenElec had working drivers way before that.

eBay are currently running a 20% off promo (see: http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18698227 ) so you're looking at £50.65 delivered less 20% making it £40.52 all in before 10pm today, also pulls the 2820 to £88ish barebone.
 
Last edited:
I have had numerous HTPCs and devices. I currently have a NUC, Arctic MC001 and a Minix NeoX8-h.... But I have just bought a 19 quid FireTv stick and it's a phenomenal bit of kit! Kodi runs as well, if not better than all my other device. It's simple and slick and I will be getting a FireTV to replace the Minix.
 
Fire TV is a great shout in general - especially if you have prime, but the lack of Windows and torrent's means it's probably not a great fit based on the OP's stated requirements.
 
So just came across this now.
I currently have a NUC 2820 wired to a 20TB library of movies on a NAS.
So far no issues at all really.

I see the i3/i5 NUCs mentioned, but what really is the difference when compared to the 2820, what can / cannot you do between these models? Is there much of a visual / performance boost?

Looking to future content and with newer TV models supporting HDMI 2.0 and HDCP 2.2, none of the Intel NUCs seem to support these.
So would A nvidea shield be the best alternative for now? esepcially the 16GB version?
 
Back
Top Bottom