Soldato
It amazes me that CGI hair looks more real than the real hair on the puppet.
Star Wars blu ray sept 2011
- Thread starter lunarwolf
- Start date
The point of changing something is to enhance whats already there not just for the sake of it.
Vader saying nothing said more than what they have added
Its pointless change and its ruins the scene.
Lucas has lost the plot
Man of Honour
... and guess what the same discussion is going on here:
http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18313231
Was thinking the same Easy, been looking forward to this box set.
Not so sure now, was gona pre order but i'll wait now to see some more reviews
More sillyness
Lol, i've got the originals on vhs so i'll proberly get these in the end.
might wait and see if they re-relese them at a later date after the die hards refuse to buy them
Is this rule different on every sub forum?
although i think cgi yoda is better, i agree that these sound effects aren't very good.
but it's really minor compared to seeing the movies in HD glory, so I can't wait. (seems like just a couple of tweaks, so not many - less than when the DVD were released if i remember correctly)
@ >£60, it comes out to less than £10 per movie so pretty good deal compared to Lotro (extended versions on 2 discs per movie!)
Last edited:
Caporegime
no just some moderators don't understand the rules
Its been clarified time and time again that discussing where to buy products that OcUK don't stock in any shape or form (like DVDs) its fine to mention places that might also sell stuff that ocuk sells, providing they don't have the same primary market as OcUK.
For example, trying to forbid us from mentioning tesco or asda is just pointless. Everybody has heard of them.
Suspended
- Joined
- 18 Oct 2002
- Posts
- 31,179
Whaaaaaaaaat a load of balls these edits are, **** you George I was planning to buy these but now you can forget it!
Soldato
Cant want for the starwars marathon to begin gonna look awsome in 1080p on my projector. 
You think that the additions Lucas has made, has improved the films?
I'd say that some of them have.
The originals came out when cgi was very much in it's infancy. Hell, they were still inventing it as they went along! A lot of the effects he's added, were done because the technology NOW exists to allow him to do it as he wants. He was constrained when the movies were made and ultimately frustrated that he couldn't do everything he wanted.
The flipside of that though is that some of it is indeed unnecessary tinkering. The extra dialogue and changing of scenes (Han not firing first springs to mind) are just change for changes sake. Also Lucas does seem to think more is better: "why only have 100 droids when we can have 10000?"
AND, if you can, have a look at an old version of the movies, on VHS if available, they look really horrible, pre-restoration. I'm pretty sure space isn't a murky brown colour.
The originals came out when cgi was very much in it's infancy. Hell, they were still inventing it as they went along! A lot of the effects he's added, were done because the technology NOW exists to allow him to do it as he wants. He was constrained when the movies were made and ultimately frustrated that he couldn't do everything he wanted.
The flipside of that though is that some of it is indeed unnecessary tinkering. The extra dialogue and changing of scenes (Han not firing first springs to mind) are just change for changes sake. Also Lucas does seem to think more is better: "why only have 100 droids when we can have 10000?"
AND, if you can, have a look at an old version of the movies, on VHS if available, they look really horrible, pre-restoration. I'm pretty sure space isn't a murky brown colour.
Sums it up
I think on the whole it's improved. Plus it will be nice to have a consolidated box set. I still find the first 3 films (bar older Anakin) quite enjoyable, just in a slightly different way to the old 3 (First as in Ep 1 2 3).