Summer Transfer Window 22/23
- Thread starter robfosters
- Start date
Soldato
No, they haven't. Last 3 have been Muscular and hip flexor. Missing 13 games due to it. 2 different injuries, not the same place.
Here is the breakdown of injuries. I don't know how someone can say he's injury prone though
Erling Haaland - Injury history
This is the injury history of Erling Haaland from Manchester City. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
Here's Mane as a random pick
Sadio Mané - Injury history
This is the injury history of Sadio Mané from Al-Nasr Riad. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
Last edited:
No, they haven't. Last 3 have been Muscular and hip flexor. Missing 13 games due to it. 2 different injuries, not the same place.
Here is the breakdown of injuries. I don't know how someone can say he's injury prone though
Erling Haaland - Injury history
This is the injury history of Erling Haaland from Manchester City. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.www.transfermarkt.co.uk
Here's Mane as a random pick
Sadio Mané - Injury history
This is the injury history of Sadio Mané from Al-Nasr Riad. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
lol youve posted that list and cant see why he's injury prone?
21/22 season
muscular - 42 days - 6 games
hip flexor - 35 days - 7 games
muscular - 18 days - 3 games
so this season alone hes missed 16 games and 95 days
thats almost a 1/4 of the year
but you dont see why people think hes injury prone?
really......
Soldato
one particularly bad year, is that predictive? Not really. They've been different areas on his body. He's a young forward against physical defenders. Anyway, this is all a bit daft. The City medical team obvs don't think he's injury prone.
20/21 was basically the same he had 4 bouts of injurys on the sideline missing a total of 10 games
the boys got paper legs
Soldato
Would you class someone like Smith Rowe injury prone as well?
are we talking about haaland or are you trying to take the debate somewhere else
Soldato
Providing context.
Emile Smith Rowe - Injury history
This is the injury history of Emile Smith Rowe from FC Fulham. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
So do you consider Smith Rowe injury prone?
I personally wouldn't. He had a couple of unfortunate injuries
Arsenal fan forums certainly seem to think Smith Rowe is injury proneProviding context.
Emile Smith Rowe - Injury history
This is the injury history of Emile Smith Rowe from FC Fulham. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
So do you consider Smith Rowe injury prone?
I personally wouldn't. He had a couple of unfortunate injuries
Caporegime
Even if he only plays 3/4 of the season he will probably still bang in a bucket load.
I know there's this automatic assumption that he'll score goals for fun and City will win everything, the League Cup, FA Cup, PL, CL, Super Bowl etc etc but City will have to make a fundamental change to how they play to fit him in. Maybe it will work and he'll score for fun and City will be even stronger or maybe he'll become another Ibrahimovic and Pep will just not be able to find a way to fit a big powerful centre forward into his side.
Soldato
Hasn't been over the last couple of years though. I remember the talk of Smith Rowe being injury prone, but he's worked through it. That's the point im making, a bad year at Dortmund isn't predictive that it'll be like that for the remainder of his career. Is Harry Kane injury prone?
Just this season by the look out of it, being knocked out of the cups early and having no European football has clearly helped him in that regard - we'll see if he holds up next year when you have a far busier schedule.
Soldato
..i don't think he'll play every game anyway, it's not advisable to play a 21yo 50/60 games a season.
Caporegime
Flog him for 3-4 years and then sell him for a ridiculous amount. Unless he has a massive fall off in form or horrible injury record he will be great for City and they will make a lot of money if they ever decide to sell him.
Its not about playing 50 or 60 games a season, Smith Rowe hasn't always started in the league, he's come off the bench quite a few times. But the difference to getting game time at weekends and then having a European game during the week is huge compared to being able to manage an injury prone player once a week.
Bit of an odd comparison. In 20/21 and 21/22 Haaland has had 6 musculoskeletal injuries, and Mane has had none.No, they haven't. Last 3 have been Muscular and hip flexor. Missing 13 games due to it. 2 different injuries, not the same place.
Here is the breakdown of injuries. I don't know how someone can say he's injury prone though
Erling Haaland - Injury history
This is the injury history of Erling Haaland from Manchester City. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
Here's Mane as a random pick
Sadio Mané - Injury history
This is the injury history of Sadio Mané from Al-Nasr Riad. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.
Edit: Jury's out on him in my book. The best people to know how worthwhile the risk is at this stage are City - they'll have given him rigorous medicals and decided he's worth whatever risk is there.
Caporegime
Didn't his Dad have dodgy knees and it wasn't actually Keane's tackle that really ended his career?