Supernatural or Smallville.
- Thread starter Riiya
- Start date
Soldato
- Joined
- 4 May 2004
- Posts
- 3,270
Supernatural is far better, but still does get a bit repetitive in the latest season.
Soldato
Supernatural is far more consistent in quality. The first 4 or so season of smallville are worth watching if you want to
Soldato
Smallville is a poor mans Buffy.
Nearly everything they do is stolen from that or other shows.
Characters don't grow and nothing is ever really resolved.
They also resort to nonsensical rubbish to keep characters like Lana and Lionel in the show.
The writers seem to think Chloe is veronica mars and give her the most annoying dialog you will ever hear.
Lastly, the whole "is he good or evil" dance they do with Lex got old after the first few years and perhaps epitomizes the greater problem of over doing an idea and not moving forward.
That being said, I still watch it because louise lane is hot.
Supernatural is a little shallow perhaps but is great fun.
It doesn't take itself too seriously and Dean is very funny.
Its by far the more enjoyable show.
Agreed, I still watch it but there's way too many fillers, there's so many better shows out there getting cancelled and this keeps going.
It's the same thing every ep.
Bad guy/mutant.... supes gets owned by kryptonite, get's saved by buddy x/y/z. Rinse Repeat.
:/
Soldato
smallville rocks, so does supernatural though 
I loved smallville but for some reason I've never watched the new season.. think I have enough with Reaper/NCIS/House and the up and coming Heroes.
Not seen Supernatural TBH, Might give that a go this week.
Smallville is cool though, yes it doesn't even try and stick to the DC comic storyline but its just good fun. Chole just does it for me, shes sooo pretty.
Not seen Supernatural TBH, Might give that a go this week.
Smallville is cool though, yes it doesn't even try and stick to the DC comic storyline but its just good fun. Chole just does it for me, shes sooo pretty.
Soldato
Agreed, however Smallville's storylines lately have dropped in quality imo. The latter seasons have just bored me and even the current storyline is just too far fetched I find. I get the feeling the writers haven't a clue where the story is now going. It just seems to be all over the place.Both, they're both excellent.
Supernatural is superb and hopefully with the writers strike over it'll be on more often. I've always liked Supernatural, it's always reminded me of X-Files in some way and I think the chemistry between the two brothers is great. Groundhog Day eps f t w!
Last edited:
Soldato
Smallvile is amazing at times and a little twee at others (due to the generational thing). Anyhow-some of the best special effects going: which get better beyond series 6.
Soldato
Supernatural for the win
Officer: "omg what have i done ive shot the sheriff"
Dean: "yeah but you didnt shoot the deputy"
supernatural makes me laugh in a way that other shows just can't. The dry humour is great. Smallville is very good, but Supernatural for me.
Soldato
- Joined
- 13 Sep 2007
- Posts
- 3,951
Edited fo' real truth.
Out of the two, I'd say Smallville. I still have a thing for Allison Mack (Chloe)!
Wrong and wrong again
Really? So is Lana...*spoiler alert*
[Highlight below]
A witch, a vampire slayer, a surveillance expert or an evil genius this week? And do you really still care about lex?
They have been teasing his turn to full out evil for 8 years!
[/Highlight]
Last edited:
Nope
edit - Oh..didn't read the whole spoiler think
It's just a bit of fun though...isn't it?
Last edited: