Tape archive software - options?

Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
7,139
Location
Ironing
I'm currently spec'ing out a tape archival solution for a group that wants to use Final Cut Server as a video editing asset manager.

I'm planning on using a Solaris/ZFS pool as the main online storage pool for FCS. What I'd like to be able to do is to archive assets off to tape that are older than 2 years (for example). FCS itself doesn't have any concept of tape drives, but it can mount different network storage pools (either over FC, iSCSI, CIFS etc.) and I can script within it to move assets older than a certain period of time between different storage pools.

I saw a demo of a product called XenData, which runs on a windows box with a tape library plugged into it. It presents a windows shared directory over the network, and basically takes anything that's written to that dir and dumps it to tape. Anything that's requested from that dir, it then pulls from tape. You can also set up rules to maintain a disk-cache, so that archived files requested often are kept on both local disk as well as tape. The nice thing about that is that clients don't care that it's a tape drive, it just looks like a high-latency windows share. The problem is that it's Windows-only.

Are there any other bits of tape archive software out there that work in a similar way? I've looked at things like Backup Exec, but that seems to be more geared to a multiple-system / agent software approach, rather than something more centralised.
 
I'm currently spec'ing out a tape archival solution for a group that wants to use Final Cut Server as a video editing asset manager.

I'm planning on using a Solaris/ZFS pool as the main online storage pool for FCS. What I'd like to be able to do is to archive assets off to tape that are older than 2 years (for example). FCS itself doesn't have any concept of tape drives, but it can mount different network storage pools (either over FC, iSCSI, CIFS etc.) and I can script within it to move assets older than a certain period of time between different storage pools.

I saw a demo of a product called XenData, which runs on a windows box with a tape library plugged into it. It presents a windows shared directory over the network, and basically takes anything that's written to that dir and dumps it to tape. Anything that's requested from that dir, it then pulls from tape. You can also set up rules to maintain a disk-cache, so that archived files requested often are kept on both local disk as well as tape. The nice thing about that is that clients don't care that it's a tape drive, it just looks like a high-latency windows share. The problem is that it's Windows-only.

Are there any other bits of tape archive software out there that work in a similar way? I've looked at things like Backup Exec, but that seems to be more geared to a multiple-system / agent software approach, rather than something more centralised.

Hi,

I would suggest looking at the link below. I have used tapes in my work and found them nothing but trouble.

http://www.2s2d.net/2009/04/19/enterprise-backup-on-hard-drives-using-esata-docks/

I have not used the suggestion in the link but I would still recommend it over tapes.
 
The team in question do disk archiving at the moment. It's inefficient, expensive (compared to LTO5), not portable (you're locked to a given filesystem) and difficult to centralise / integrate with systems like FCS.

The only thing that disks give you over tapes for long time archive is speed of transfer, and that's not something I care about as much as the other factors. I appreciate that tapes aren't for everything, but I don't see physical disks as being a long-term viable solution.
 
Back
Top Bottom