Technical question: Saute pan with non-stick coating

Associate
Joined
23 Mar 2006
Posts
906
Location
Guildford, Surrey
So I've got myself all flustered having just put £50 down on a saute pan with a non-stick coating.

To lay out all the features of the pan, it's hard anodised, with a tri-ply base (aluminium core), has a capacity of about 2.8 litres and its lidded.

I bought the pan with a few ideas in mind. Being non-stick and a saute pan kinda felt like a contradiction, since I won't be able to have it on a very high heat, but then I thought if it distributes heat properly it won't need it. What I've got in mind for it is things like on-the-hob stews and casseroles, risottos, curries, ragus, hob tagines, bolognese, fajita/taco fillings, braising, steaming and frying. I think that realistically, all this is achievable either on a low heat by slow cooking, or on normal heat, but obviously not up high. I frankly even feel it'll be fine for sauted vegetables and potatoes.

Now to detract from the fact that I seem to have it all sussed - I'm doubting myself because a friend of mine, who is a chef, seemed to find the idea of a non-stick saute pan ridiculous. So I'm now left wondering if I should return it and get a stainless steel pan with an aluminium base.

All you budding pan enthusiasts out there, do you think this pan will happily serve my needs, or have I bought a dud?
 
Apparently, non-stick coatings naturally degrade if you have them on the hob too high?

I never quite understood this, as a I have a £15 frypan from sainsburys that is non-stick and has lasted without degrading for 2 years.

What's the purpose of coating in oil if I may ask?
 
Ok, so i just saw this on Wikipedia

Non-stick frying pans featuring teflon coatings must never be heated above about 465 °F/240 °C, a temperature that easily can be reached in minutes.[3] At higher temperatures non-stick coatings decompose and give off toxic fumes.[4][5

Now I have my non-stick frying pan very hot, literally smoking (which I now know is toxic fumes :p) before putting food in it every single time I use the thing and can assure you it doesn't make the food taste any different and I've had no ill-effects from it.

Also your frying pan (it is basically an overpriced frying pan ;)) might not use Teflon anyway.
 
Ha ha, thanks for doing some research to bring some facts to the table!

I agree.. it probably is an overpriced frying pan! But I reckon it'll do what I want it to well.

As for the smoking, I've done that before, little did I realise I was toxifying my bacon! Saying that though, has the coating on your pan actually degraded? Because mine is still fine after 2 years.
 
Is it teflon coated, anodised generally refers to an aluminium oxide coating. I thought the anodised pans weren't teflon coated and thus were more versatile. Have you checked the manufacturers info on the pan you've bought because I have afeeling it will not be teflon coated.

edit: had a quick look, I might be wrong there. You do get teflon coated anodised pans.
 
Last edited:
Is it teflon coated, anodised generally refers to an aluminium oxide coating. I thought the anodised pans weren't teflon coated and thus were more versatile. Have you checked the manufacturers info on the pan you've bought because I have afeeling it will not be teflon coated.

edit: had a quick look, I might be wrong there. You do get teflon coated anodised pans.

doesn't appear to be teflon, here is said pan for reference:

http://www.meyergroup.co.uk/circulon/infinite.html
 
Anodised is not teflon.
I have numerous infinite circulon pans and heat them up on full whack for significant periods of time and have had no ill effects so far.
 
Personally I wouldn't use non-stick for various reasons. I can only speak from the experience I have (of owning an All-Clad 3qt saute pan) so... If given the choice, I'd always choose a stainless steel pan as it doesn't have any health risks (that I know of), they can be used on a higher heat which means you can achieve a better browning (Maillard reaction) and most importantly unlike non-stick, stainless steels pans develop a fond when you saute in them.

Providing the pan is of good quality. Stainless steel is just as easy to keep clean and will last longer.

If anyone's interested, after searching for three weeks. I found that firstireland.com is the cheapest place in the UK to buy All-Clad.
 
given the prices of the all clad range it's not wonder they're going to perform better! I think I got my money's worth paying £50 for some circulon!

Some of it is overpriced but I think it was worth spending the money I did as there's a good chance it'll last for decades, which of course it'll work out cheaper in the long run... plus, they're bloody gorgeous. There is a cheaper alternative in the USA called Tramontina (which is said to be almost as good) that's much cheaper but I can't find it anywhere in the UK.
 
Back
Top Bottom