The first game was great.
However imo first Darksiders had two weak points:
1) Throughout the game there was a sense of isolation or cut off from anykind of meaningful social environment which itself wasn't great, as you explored the environment with War (the background environment should have been more lively)
2) The 'Destroyer' turned out to be such a disappointment. 'Straga' looked impressive and should have been the final boss.