the devs are a-holes. The "game", is pure crap. Bad modelling, bad scripting (birds flying through buildings and floors now?) Bad animations, bad concept.. bad trees (a rotating plane is not a tree.)
The 'game' isn't marketed on it's fantastic cryengine graphics, so to complain about them is redundant.
In your personal opinion, the concept is 'bad' - but this is purely personal opinion. For what the game describes itself as, I feel it succeeds. I feel the intent and meaning behind the piece is portrayed well, and the concept is intriguing.
How this makes the developers "a-holes", I've no idea. Just because it's not your average, ten-a-penny fps doesn't mean it deserves to be shunned - if it was Machina made in the Source engine, I'm sure it'd be getting much more respect. I'm not telling you to like it, I just don't understand how anyone can be appalled by it!