Tomato WRT54GL to DIR-655 - question regarding WRT throughput and reboots

mrk

mrk

Man of Honour
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
105,260
Location
South Coast
So I’ve bought a DLink DIR-655 router after having a WRT54GL v1.1 for many many years of trouble free routing (kek!) until I upgraded to 20MB cable.

The problem I experience is random soft reboots, the router will reboot/reconnect itself every few days, mostly in the late/early hours so not a major issue but on rare occasions I’d see it reboot itself during a L4D game at an early evening time!

I’ve been trying Tomato, DD-WRT and HyperWRT-Thibor-15c and all exhibit this issue.

I chose to stick with tomato though as it allows me to keep a scheduled 5am reboot to avoid it rebooting itself at any other time which I found to work quite well.

I did a bit of digging and found a fair number of people reporting the same issue on 20MB and the fact that many routers inc the WRT doesn’t have a 20MB stable LAN<>WAN throughput. I have 4 wireless users and 3 wired users connected to the WRT at any one time so this would explain that and the reason why it was perfectly fine on 10MB but showed this performance issue only when I upgraded to 20MB.

Also I need a gigabit switched router and Wireless N for current and future expansion so this would be an ideal time to upgrade. The big thing was torrents, the DIR is said to handle multiple connections with ease so this one one selling point.

I wanted to ask if anyone here has 20MB and a WRT54G and also a large number of connected machines and devices?

Also I’m looking to see a nice increase in sustained stability and performance with all clients connected :D

I’m not looking to troubleshoot the WRT54G I have, it’s not a faulty router or configured incorrectly, it works perfectly well under standard use. My home usage doesn’t really fall under “normal” use so wanted to know if anyone else has seen this throughput issue leading to the router soft-rebooting itself under heavy usage?

I have had 2x WRT54GL routers and both had the same issue so it’s not an age thing. (2 because I switched to Sky ADSL at one point due to cheapness and sold the old WRT…worst mistake ever so went back to VM and bought a new WRT :p).

I’ll report back once the DIR is installed – should be here today or tomorrow!
 
do you have link to these 20mb problems mate? just that i'm on the same package and have no problems (that i know of)..

i take it you've done a clear NVRAM on the WRT :)


let us know how that new router is, currently i'm using a gigabit switch with my WRT
 
I don't have any direct links here (at work) I browsed them from the netbook in a McDonalds over lunch last week! but I just googled various WRT54GL rebooting criteria and came across some cableforum and avforum threads which I browsed through!

I did consider a gigabit switch as it would have been a crapload cheaper but I wanted wireless N and also a free wall socket too as the living room has too many sockets in use with none free if my last venture behind the media rack was anything to go by!

Yep all firmware changes were done as a fresh install, Clear NVRAM and reset defaults. I do this periodically anyway just to clear out any logged data/files as they are 3rd party firmwares afterall 
 
I use a 5 port gigabit switch, with port 5 connected to the WRT and the rest of machines to the other gigabit ports, never had any throughput issues with 20Mb Virgin last year on this setup.
 
The router should be here tomorrow, had to cancel and reorder elsewhere due to stock<.delivery issues!
 
Just ordered a DIR 655 from fleabay £50.

I am hoping to get a more stable connection than my existing Modem / Router combo which is a speedtouch supplied by BE There.

Let us know how you get on..
 
Just ordered a DIR 655 from fleabay £50.

I am hoping to get a more stable connection than my existing Modem / Router combo which is a speedtouch supplied by BE There.

Let us know how you get on..

you know this has no adsl modem yes?
 
Got dispatch mail today so shoudl be here tomorrow :D

Shadow already has an ADSL modem as part of his current router so all he needs to do is set it to act as modem only so disabling the router functions if available.
 
Last edited:
you know this has no adsl modem yes?

Yes thanks bledd.

Aparrently the speedtouch modem/routers are prone to reboots/freezes when under heavy usage; ie. Many wifi connections/ large file transfers on lan / bittorrent - it's not the modem more the router side of things that causes the problem.

So I will be reconfiguring the modem to 'pass thru' and let the 655 handle the Wifi/Wan/routing stuff.

Thats the theory anyway (i've seen many posts that say the speedtouch works fine this way and gets around the problem.)
 
Router came today and I've been messing around with it this eve also updated the latest firmware (love the built in firmware checker and downloader!).

Router has some excellent features, things the WRT does not have even with Tomato etc like Emailing logs when logfile is full and email notifications for other stuff etc.

Also the VPN side may be useful in the near future for me.

I like the interface very much, it's very easy to be able to see connected wired and wireless devices one by one and administer restrictions and traffic shaping - many options to play with!

So far stability seems very good although to my horror I found out that the NEW Dell PC downstairs only has a 10/100 nic and not 10/100/1000 !!!

WIll get a gigabit nic and also a wireless N USB card as well as a mini pcie N card for my samsung NC10 soon to get the network up to gigabit speeds with the rest of the machines :)


Anyone want a WRT54G? it is lonely....

router_wrt54glv1.1.jpg
 
I could always use a 2nd WRT54G, my brother "borrowed" mine last year and I'm still missing it lol Email's in trust, unless you want to put it in MM for all to see? At least link me if you do please. :D
 
Never had any problems with 20mb using Tomato (WRT54GS-v4), & I quite regularly pull down upwards of 40gb a day. (1 server, on constantly- Torrents, usenet etc, Desktop- RS/ MU & games, 3 pure consoles & 2 XBMCs)
Current uptime: 43 days, 11:14:41
Its far more likely you needed a few QOS rules applying, plus TCP Vegas.

DD-WRT on the other hand is a buggy POS, & the author has some very questionable baggage in tow. (Various ripping off of other FOSS etc)

-Leezer-
 
2 days 1hr uptime so far (settings set just how I like them now) with 36.8GB downloaded in those 49hrs and not a single issue.

3 Wireless clients connected with the Wii connected every now and then plus 2 wireless which are on 24/7 oh and the HDTV box.

Happy!
 
does it have..
static hdcp?


ie, assigning a certain IP to a certain MAC address, using the router's firmware
 
does it have..
static hdcp?


ie, assigning a certain IP to a certain MAC address, using the router's firmware


Why would it have HD Content Protection? :D

It does have static DHCP though as well as other expected features like DynDNS updater and D-link's own free DNS service

routerdhcp.JPG
 
Back
Top Bottom