Critique my proposed network please!

Soldato
Joined
6 Oct 2004
Posts
18,431
Location
Birmingham
Edit: Scrapped original idea

My current network is in a bit of a mess, currently running:
  • VM Hub in Modem Mode
    • Current Router - TP-Link Archer C5400X (8 ports)
      • My main PC
      • Game server
      • Cat 6 to 5 port gigabit switch in TV unit (Netgear GS205)
        • Sky Box
        • Nvidia Shield
        • Nintendo Switch
      • 5 Port 100mbs switch (some cheapy TP link thing)
        • Hue Bridge
        • Tado Bridge
        • Alarm hub
        • Ancient 8 port PoE switch (GS108PEv2)
          • Proxmox server (running HA/Frigate/Octopi)
          • POE Camera
          • POE Camera

We've just moved the Virgin point upstairs to my office, so I can consolidate everything (previously the hub and router were both in the TV unit, running via the cat 6 connection to the office). Wifi in the rest of the house is a bit pants now, so wanting to install at least 1 decent AP. My proposed new idea is:
  • VM Hub in Modem Mode
    • Current Router - TP-Link Archer C5400X (8 ports), with wifi disabled
      • My main PC
      • Game server
      • Cat 6 to 5 port gigabit switch in TV unit (Netgear GS205)
        • Sky Box
        • Nvidia Shield
        • Nintendo Switch
      • 8 Port Gigabit POE+ switch (TP-Link LS108GP)
        • Ubiquiti U6 Pro (ceiling of upstairs landing)
        • POE Camera
        • POE Camera
        • Hue Bridge
        • Tado Bridge
        • Alarm hub
        • Proxmox server (running HA/Frigate/Octopi)

Additional proposed changes:

  • Swap the current router (it's a bit of a beast) for a Ubiquiti "Cloud Gateway Ultra" - any worth in doing this?
  • Maybe an additional U6 Pro on the ceiling of the downstairs hallway. Not sure this will be necessary as it's only a 3 bed mid-terrace, so not exactly huge.
Queries:

Is this a decent use of switches? I wasn't sure if I'd be better getting a standard non-PoE 8 (or even 16) port switch for the non-PoE devices, and a smaller 5 port PoE switch connected into that for those which need it - tbh I can't envision ever needing more than 4 in the current house (the 2 cameras and the max 2 APs)?

Is there any benefit in getting Ubiquiti switches if the rest of my kit is also Ubiquiti, or just stick with the cheap & cheerful TP-Link/Netgear?
Is there any benefit in a 16 port vs 2x 8 port switches, other than smaller footprint?

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom