Was Beckham's treatment after WC98 warranted? (and a slice of personal 90s nostalgia...)

Man of Honour
Joined
25 Oct 2002
Posts
31,869
Location
Hampshire
So I've watched the first couple of episodes of the Beckham documentary which has contained no surprises so far but did make me feel a bit nostalgic for the 90s (especially a whole segment with Supersonic in the background). When I was at school I saw Beckham playing on loan at Notts County and then some league cup game or something. I was really impressed and telling my close friends about how great he was, how hard he struck the ball. This was before he was even known by most fans never mind a household name, he wasn't in the first team. Then coming back for sixth form in 1996 after he hit that halfway line goal vs Wimbledon I was smug as, "told ya!" bla bla. Point being I've always had a soft spot for him because I "discovered him" (clearly he was discovered long before but even some Man United fans didn't really know about him, no internet back then).
By WC'98 he was established, as an 18yo it was also my first tournament watching games in the pub, to this day I've still NEVER experienced an atmosphere excluding stadiums like the Columbia game, when he scored that freekick, it was absolute bedlam. SOOOO good.

And then of course we come to the subject of this thread, the red card vs Argentina. At the time I was a bit torn, he was a favourite of mine but also when you're a teenager the WC is a big deal, literally my only memories of it were getting robbed by Maradona, penalty heartbreak against west germany and that's it (didn't qualify in '94). So there was that undertone of resentment there, getting himself sent off in such a stupid, petulant way. To be honest, I pretty much wanted to move on quickly but ALSO I did kind of relish the treatment he was getting, and was a bit surprised when it faded away. Like he scores a freekick against Greece in 2001 and suddenly all is forgiven, tbh it had died down a lot by then anyway. I had visions of him getting abused for life.

Watching the documentary, which clearly will be positioned a certain way, I'm left feeling that it was a bit over the top. He's got sent off for a moment of madness, but do we really need hanging effigies, death threats to his parents house, the 90s red top media circus (remember this is the days of full on stalking / phone hacking / hounding Diana etc)?
When a similar situation happened with Rooney, there was for sure a media storm but it died out a lot quicker and never reached the same heights.
Basically I feel like there was a line that was crossed there, the country needed a scapegoat and he was the obvious target but I really wouldn't want to have been in his shoes, you might be a millionaire playing for your country and shagging a pop star but getting spat on in the street by people you've never met, can't pull your curtains without a hundred flash blubs going off etc, that would wear you down after a whiie.
 
Didn't realise he played for Notts County. Knew he was at Preston for a bit.

I'm with you, I was 21 at the time and football was life. It felt somehow warranted but in hindsight it was whipped up by the media and stoked by that idiot Hoddle who clearly threw him under the bus. Made us forget that other professional and more experienced footballers missed a set shot from 12 yards out that would have put us through. It was easy for me to dislike him then as a Newcastle lad in the late 90's. I hated the lot of them but I guess we all grow up and mature. Ironically him and Gary Neville were the two I disliked the most however follow a lot of the stuff they do these days. They were just young lads playing for a team they loved.

I was watching it with my Mrs and she was shocked but the Aussies don't really get it. I can only imagine the toll it took on his mental health. Its a little surprising he didnt off himself tbh. I booed and jeered him at St James park. If he ever wants to meet me for a pint I'd happily apologise.
 
I was probably too young at 12 to really understand the whole thing. I was just a kid gutted at being out of the world cup, but the next day i was probably back playing footy in the park!

Having watched the documentary it's hard not to feel sorry for him and place a lot of blame on Hoddle. I don't think i'd ever realised the extent to him throwing him under the bus, although obviously the documentary highlights it a lot.

I wonder if as a country we learnt a lot when it came to Rooney which is why it wasn't worse, along with the fact that the media directly a lot of it at the "winker"
 
I was at Selhurst Park when he scored from the halfway line, I was with my uncle and nephew who were diehard United Fans.

Last Premiership game I went to!
 
Was it over the top .. yes very much so..

But then look at the behaviour of some fans at every single football game. It's disgusting.

( I must add most fans are about supporting the team, not jeering the opposition, but i'm sure if you go to football you know the people i'm talking about! )

However it seems when I usually bring this up around hardened football supporters, it's all "part of the bants", "just having a laugh", "Atmosphere", "It's a passionate game!".. None of which are excuses for the behaviour!

I love football, but can't stand the associated tribal nature of it all, hence why I don't go to watch live games anymore, and I almost preferred watching when it was all empty stadiums.

R.
 
I could sort of understand the frustration if they had lost the game during the 90 mins, but they made it through extra time and then took a few awful penalties... The amount of blame he got was ridiculous.

I'd say Kane sending that second penalty to space against France with 6-7 minutes left was far worse, and he didn't get much stick for it at all (thankfully).
 
We were very close to winning Euro 96. The expectation from the boys was massive and we were far the better team than Argentina.

He got the stick because he was representing the country and let them down. Just like Phil Neville did when he dumped us out of Euro 2000. I guess Beckham can thank his lucky stars he didn't play for Columbia.

He could have been one of England's greats but he let it all get too his head really and Fergie could see this and got rid of him and partially why Hoddle dropped him. He was basically retired at 32 years old which was far too soon for him really.
 
Last edited:
No it wasn’t warranted, he got slaughtered for years. Did he make a silly mistake? Of course, should he have gotten the abuse he did? No.
 
Back
Top Bottom