Weird Problem

Soldato
Joined
18 Jan 2003
Posts
5,995
Location
Expat in the USA
Looking for idea's that I may be missing.

I recently installed a new 2TB Hitachi HD on my slightly aging Q6600 system. Mobo is a Asus P5Q Pro. Boot drive is a segate 640gb 7200rpm, not that it matters but my memory is gskill 1333 and my gfx is x-fired 5770's

Anyway, my weird problem started last week. I removed an 1TB drive and put in a new 2TB drive.. My bios is the latest from the Asus website 2102, but that's from 2009....

The computer is fine for most of the time, but perhaps in 1 of 5 boots (completely randomly might i add) it takes forever to boot. With random results. For example, it may just not boot, or one time the new HD wasdetected as something weird, like a Hitachi HDS5C30 @)@)@)( (in device manager) or it's detected as normal, but if you try and click on it, another time it wasn't showing me the correct drive letter, and if i tried to go into it, it was advising me to format it as the file system is not reckonised.

But then on the other 4 out of 5 boots, it's absolutely fine ????

Do you reckon i just have a bad drive? that i should RMA, or a bios compatibilty issue? But the issue only shows its ugly face every now and again.

I kind of feel I'm chasing my own tail here. At first I thought i had a bad DVD drive, cos the machine wouldn't even boot, until i unplugged the power and IDE from the device. Then it worked for 5 times, and i thought sweet, just a bad dvd drive.. But then, after a few normal reboots, weird things started happening again, as above..

I'm guessing it's gotta be the drive, since everything was running sweet up until last week when i put it in.. Maybe a compatibility issue? But why does it sometimes work then? I'm guessing i'm going to have to do a divide and conquer here, and start that off, by replacing the drive with a different one.

Any other thoughts that I maybe missing?
 
Last edited:
Have you tried switching the 2TB drive to a different SATA port on the motherboard? I would suggest switching it with a known good port, unless you only have the two HDDs in there that means swapping your boot drive to a potentially damaged port - which is probably not a good idea.

EDIT - I know you mentioned you removed a working 1TB drive from the port so it should be OK, but there's always a chance the port or cable got damaged during the change-over.
 
Back
Top Bottom