Where do I stand legally?

Caporegime
Joined
24 Oct 2012
Posts
26,100
Location
Yer nan's knickers
Bought car from Marshalls Hampshire in 2021.

That dealer has since been an absolute abortion in terms if service and underhand sneaky extra charges so whilst the reputation of Marshalls was already in the toilet, I was locked in to their warranty scheme so just used another branch, which is Bournemouth.

The sunroof broke a month ago and won't close, and Marshall's were beyond useless. The soonest they could see the car was in 6 weeks. Cue a few more calls with the frustration levels increasing each time as they made it very clear that they didn't give a toss but took the calls as an opoortunity to try sell me an oil change (which was done a month ago at their own bloody workshop).

Eventually I get through to someone who finds a slot for the 5th of July. Ok so it's almost a month away but I can make it work. I ask the guy to send me a confirmation email, he says he will, he doesn't. I ring back the next day, "yes sir, no problem, we'll send it to you now". Still nothing. So that's two confirmations that it's booked in and two promises of an email, nothing shows up of course.

Today's the day and surprise surprise, no booking and they can't see me. After a bit of heated negotiating they're now trying to shut the sunroof so we can at least use the car.

Tl;dr - I've been lied to, fobbed off, ignored and despite numerous attempts to get this resolved in a decent manner, Marshalls have made it abundantly clear that they just don't care.

So, legal then. I would like my extended warranty cancelled and the remaining duration refunded. Ideally I also want to go full Karen and make them pay for my wasted day and tank of fuel.

I'm fairly flexible when things go wrong, but the total refusal to give me a service I've paid for has pushed me to the point of no return.

I'm sure some others on here have dealt with this kind of thing before, any tips?
 
Final letter before action before you can go legal.

Detail *every* *tiny* *thing* to the date and the problems etc.

Then your expected remedy and a timeframe to sort it.

Did you take any of it on finance?
 
You need to up your Karen game, show them you're a real baller, a Gucci handbag with a Pomeranian in it should do the trick. That way, they'll do everything they can to keep you as a customer and buy a more expensive car that you don't need in the future.

For real though:

Document Everything: Make sure you have documentation for everything you are claiming. You'll need this for any legal action or complaint you may lodge. This includes all communication (emails, messages, phone call logs), all service appointments, proof of payments, etc.

Write a Formal Letter: Draft a formal letter to the dealership detailing your grievances. Make it clear that you expect your warranty to be cancelled and refunded for the remaining duration. Also state that you expect compensation for your wasted time and resources. Make sure to include all the necessary details of your case and what you've suffered through as a result of their poor service. Send this letter via recorded delivery so that you have proof it was received.

Contact Consumer Protection: If the dealership is unwilling to resolve the issue to your satisfaction, you may need to contact your local consumer protection agency.

Leave Reviews: Write about your experience on platforms such as Google Reviews, Trustpilot etc and any other websites where the dealership is listed. Be factual and as detailed as possible.

Contact a Trade Association: If the dealership is part of a trade association, you can lodge a complaint with them.

If none of that works then legal action if you can afford it and it's worth the hassle.
 
Last edited:
Well this just gets better and better. Been sitting in their waiting area whilst they see if they can temporarily close the sunroof, no joy. So I end up chatting to the (admittedly rather helpful) chap who tells me they booked me in at the wrong branch, and that I'm another two hours away from the correct branch.

They're now calling the warranty company to see if they can provide me with a courtesy car.

I ******* *hate* car dealers.
 
Industry in general not just dealers :( why I use a Nissan dealer near me a lot as they are one of the few who still seem to give a good level of customer service and prices aren't bad, though sadly increasing the last few months, by dealer standards albeit not cheap.
 
Had a run-in with a Marshalls dealership many years ago, and never again. They were an absolutely stereotype of a 'dodgy car dealer' - lies, fob-offs, not returning calls, 'they all do that, sir'.
I ended up getting the manufacturer involved who ended up offering an ~80% 'good will' reduction on the work, but I was still out of pocket hundreds of pounds barely 3 months after buying the car.

The whole experience was exhausting and you couldn't pay me to go back.
 
My local Smart main dealer aren't the cheapest but they are honest and trustworthy. They do what they say and have great customer service. I know I can trust them. Received an official document regarding my three year service plan the other week.

They've done the A service and note that it expires in 2026 after a B service in 2024 and a C service in 2025.
 
My local Smart main dealer aren't the cheapest but they are honest and trustworthy. They do what they say and have great customer service. I know I can trust them. Received an official document regarding my three year service plan the other week.

They've done the A service and note that it expires in 2026 after a B service in 2024 and a C service in 2025.
You were 2 seconds away from firing off a complaint email to them not that long ago for poor customer service:p
 
Last edited:
You were 2 seconds away from firing off a complaint email to them not that long ago for poor customer service:p
No I wasn’t, I was just concerned that they were using the correct part numbers. I just left it to them in the end and they came through.
 
Well, I've just paid a tenner for a uber then £56 for a train back home. Sat there for three hours in their waiting room whilst they figured out which is their elbow and which is their ********. Apparently the car will be ready on Friday, and "as a good will gesture you won't be out of pocket". I just laughed at him whilst my brain was picturing me smashing his head against a wall.

So two days lost work, about £150 in expenses and my life shortened a few weeks with frustration.

Never again.

Oh and I even emailed the CEO, twice, and he doesn't even bother responding either. **** Marshall.
 
No I wasn’t, I was just concerned that they were using the correct part numbers. I just left it to them in the end and they came through.
I drafted the email before I found out the after sales manager had left the company on LinkedIn. May still send it to show my disappointment at the customer service I’ve received. After all how was I to know he’d left the company hence no reply.
I think you were.
 
Ah ok. For which manufacturer? You should be able pick your own dealer if its an approved used car. Any dealer in the network.
Mini, it's Marshall who do quite a few brands. Their entire network is rotten to the core. I've tried many, many times over the last month to get something out of them, anything, but I'm just constantly lied to, fobbed off, ignored, their service is non-existent.
 
Mini, it's Marshall who do quite a few brands. Their entire network is rotten to the core. I've tried many, many times over the last month to get something out of them, anything, but I'm just constantly lied to, fobbed off, ignored, their service is non-existent.

You should be able to use any MINI dealer then. Like Sytner or Soper etc.

Personally... Not heard of Marshall in the bmw/mini scene before...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom