Which cables do I require?

Associate
Joined
31 Jan 2007
Posts
603
It is 6 years since I have been involved with networking and cabling and things have moved on since.

1. My current home setup is as follows:

a. Talktalk broadband connected at 20meg.
b. Netgear DG834G v4 adsl2+ modem router
c. 1 PC with Asus P5Q Pro motherboard with E8400 C2Duo and GBIT LAN . This is an occasional IL2 game server.
d. 1 PC with Gigabyte EX58-UD5 motherboard and overclocked i7 920 with 2 x GBIT LAN.
e. 2 x eConnect HomePlugs (85meg)

The PC (Item c) is in another room and connected to the router using homeplugs. As one would expect the speed when copying from one machine to another is limited by the lan speed of the router (not being Gigabit).

2. Proposed setup:

As above, + purchasing:

a. NETGEAR GS605 5-Port Gigabit Desktop Switch.
b. QNAP TS219P or QNAP TS239 NAS (not sure yet..cannot decide). With 2 x 1tb mirrored drives. This is to hold all my music and converted camcorder videos, converted to digital 35 mm slides and other photographic prints converted to digital.
c. Netgear Digital Entertainer HD EVA8000 or EVA9150.

3. All the above hardware will be configured as follows:

a. The Netgear Gigabit switch will be plugged directly into the Netgear DG834G router with the rest of the hardware being plugged into the new Gigabit switch.
b. The Netgear Entertainer is going to sit downstairs and will be connected to my Hi Fi system and 46" Sony LCD 1080p TV for me to listen to all the music and to view the video files and the photographs. I will be using a further Homeplug to transmit the data downstairs.

Just a quick question please before I waste my money :D:

I have been looking on the web for extra network cabling to link the system and was under the impression that Cat 5e was all that was needed. In fact I had never given it a thought until I noticed in several places that people had suggested you should use Cat 6 cable. So my question is do I use Cat 5e or Cat 6 Cable and will there be any difference in speed? Any suggestions would be gratefully received and also any comments on my proposed setup.
 
No difference - just use 5e

Thanks! As I said, I had not given it a thought until I read this..

http://www.broadbandutopia.com/caandcaco.html

and this..

http://www.cat-5-cable-company.com/faq-cat6-v-cat5e.html

and this..

http://www.networkcablingdirectory.com/articles/structured-network-cabling-id_1151.htm

There are loads more using the google search!

I suppose if one can get Cat6 at Cat5e prices then it is a no brainer? I am only looking at 1 or 2 metre leads anyway.
 
Last edited:
TBH at 1 or 2m you could probably use bell wire and still get gb speeds!

I'd just get whatever's cheapest - CAT6 is generally less flexible than CAT5 (physically) which can make it a pain to run around desks sometimes (remembering if you exceed the maximum bend radius, you may as well just have CAT5)
 
http://www.broadbandutopia.com/caandcaco.html

There are lots of differences though if you are just a home user it's not really a problem.


M.

err...thanks...I had already posted that link above if you see...thanks again anyway. Looks like Cat6 cables for me as I need new ones and as has already been stated they are more sturdy.

Has anybody any comments on the QNAP TS239 or the Netgear hub that I am going to use? Anybody got the TS239 or the gigabit hub or even the Netgear Digital Entertainer HD EVA8000 or EVA9150? If so I would like to hear from you!

Thanks
 
If you can get a switch rather than a hub - the price difference isn't that much. Hub shares the bandwidth while a switch doesn't.



M.
 
Then that's fine. The only bottle neck I see is going out onto the net but unless you have a GB net connection then that shouldn't be a problem.



M.
 
He's saying that if you download a file from the internet, it won't download any faster just because you have a Gigabit LAN.

Yes thanks! I realise I cannot download any faster...it goes without saying! I am already connected at 20meg and at 1.7km from the exchange that is good:D It is my internal lan and all the hardware on that lan that I wish to ensure is running as fast as is possible. Hence the gigabit switch and the higher spec cabling!
 
The price difference is very small, so why risk having to change in a few years. Here is a lot more detailed answer: http://www.serverracksandcable.com/ArticleCat5eCat6DifferencesandBenefits.php

1. Thanks for this information. I have already decided to go down the Cat6 route and need to source the following in the UK.

a. Approximately 200 feet of white cat6 cabling.
b. RJ45 Connectors.
c. The appropriate crimp tool.
d. Wall sockets and plates.

Note. I will not be using homeplugs at any stage, and will have a fully wired setup.

Does anyone know a supplier in the UK where I can get these?

Regards
 
Last edited:
I fully understand, but they dont sell white cat6 cabling.

Nope, they dont but the competitor rules are a bit harsh IMO. I understand what they're getting at and I abide by the rules, but if theres any overlap in what they sell at all it would be considered a competitor
 
Nope, they dont but the competitor rules are a bit harsh IMO. I understand what they're getting at and I abide by the rules, but if theres any overlap in what they sell at all it would be considered a competitor

Agreed! I have just found a site that sells an unusual coloured box!:D
 
Thanks for all the replies concerning cabling. I have now found a supplier for Cat6 and that is the route I will take for future proofing.

With regards to the NAS, I have still not made up my mind about which one to purchase be it a QNAP TS219P or QNAP TS239 NAS with 2 x 1tb mirrored drives, or a Synology Disk Station DS209+ NAS server, or even a NETGEAR ReadyNAS Duo RND2110 - Storage server. Has anyone here got any of these and what are their experiences with them? If so I would be grateful if you would let me know. It always holds true that you get what you pay for, but as a home user, arent some of these over the top?

The NAS will be used to hold all my music and converted camcorder videos converted mp4, 35 mm slides and other photographic prints converted to digital. It will eventually be linked to the new Popcorn hour C200 when it is generally available.
 
Back
Top Bottom