Which fibre ISP?
- Thread starter Converge
- Start date
Soldato
- Joined
- 10 May 2004
- Posts
- 5,293
- Location
- Middlesex
BT is worse?
How much can you expect the speed to drop during peak times on a 40mbit connection?
As much as I hate to say it BT is actually pretty good for traffic shaping atm and actually quite close to "unlimited" the current system applies "soft brakes" based on overall traffic levels as well as localised contention - so even a super heavy user might not see any noticeable slowdown much of the time unless their exchange is near capacity or everyones jumped on iplayer at the same time to watch something popular - it doesn't clap on anchors any more triggered just by the user going over some magical figure, you will be flagged for going over some magical figure but won't actually notice any throttling unless other conditions are met - at which point you'd go to the top of the list and see the brakes applied a little harder than someone with lower useage should there be a bottleneck somewhere in the system.
Tho I believe P2P traffic is still managed a bit more agressively especially at peak times, but most other protocols are managed as above these days (I have no sympathy for someone using 600+gig a month and crying coz their torrents are only doing 12KB/s between 5pm and midnight).
VM is actually a lot harsher these days than BT for traffic management strangely enough.
As for gaming - BT used to be fairly good - but they tend to shove interleaving on a lot more readily these days and it can be quite a bit of hassle to get it removed, added to that their 21CN network routing is well ****** ** is putting it midly - so expect to see 20-25ms pings whereas 10ms used to be easily achieveable back when their internal network routing was better - still perfectly playable but not 100% ideal.
To give you some idea how messed up their routing is (notes are roughly what the route is rather than the exact geo-location of that IP):
Back in the day I'd route via Reading or Bletchley on a good day and Birmingham on a bad and see 12-15ms exit pings on a bad day and 9-10ms on a good.
Tho I believe P2P traffic is still managed a bit more agressively especially at peak times, but most other protocols are managed as above these days (I have no sympathy for someone using 600+gig a month and crying coz their torrents are only doing 12KB/s between 5pm and midnight).
VM is actually a lot harsher these days than BT for traffic management strangely enough.
As for gaming - BT used to be fairly good - but they tend to shove interleaving on a lot more readily these days and it can be quite a bit of hassle to get it removed, added to that their 21CN network routing is well ****** ** is putting it midly - so expect to see 20-25ms pings whereas 10ms used to be easily achieveable back when their internal network routing was better - still perfectly playable but not 100% ideal.
To give you some idea how messed up their routing is (notes are roughly what the route is rather than the exact geo-location of that IP):
Back in the day I'd route via Reading or Bletchley on a good day and Birmingham on a bad and see 12-15ms exit pings on a bad day and 9-10ms on a good.
Last edited:
18 month contract with BT would be just too long for me.
A lot can happen in 18 months, how much would BT charge to end your contract early,£10, £100 or more.?
I personally wait for a couple of months or so, & see what happening with FTTC, by then other isp's might have things up & running with fttc, like BE.
I'm desperate to move to FTTC, but I'm prepared to wait.
A lot can happen in 18 months, how much would BT charge to end your contract early,£10, £100 or more.?
I personally wait for a couple of months or so, & see what happening with FTTC, by then other isp's might have things up & running with fttc, like BE.
I'm desperate to move to FTTC, but I'm prepared to wait.
I would say so. Speed will drop to next to nothing during peak if you use torrents.
They'll charge for the months remaining in the contract.
Associate
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2009
- Posts
- 367
- Location
- Cardiff
BT - Online gaming Troubles? I've been with BT for around 18 months and I have NEVER had any online gaming troubles and I'm online gaming every day!
Soldato
- Joined
- 10 May 2004
- Posts
- 5,293
- Location
- Middlesex
Wow, that's some pretty extreme shaping. I wouldn't mind if it dropped to say, 1mbit but it will drop down to kb/s?
