Which lens to keep?

[Kronos]

Been trying to flog this lot with little success not really surprising as it is pretty much entry level and did not come with a lens. So decided to buy a second hand lens did not matter what just as long as it fitted and could take a half decent photo.

So I bought a Canon EF 28-80mm f/3.5-5.6 11 from these folk MPD which arrived today.

Now I am in a quandary as fitting this lens to the 350D and the 1100d I cannot decide if this is a better all round lens to the 18-55mm?

The 28-80 takes a cracking image but being new to DSLR cameras so much is a mystery. I do need to add a lens to the 350D for selling purposes but which one?

 

[Kronos]

Depends on what you shoot. I favour FOV over reach so would keep the 18-55 all day.

I don't really restrict my shooting, at the moment I am taking more close ups than anything, the cat, things I am selling that sort of thing. Come the warmer days I hope to get out and about but again I will mainly be indoors. Dynamic Earth, Museums ETC.

So does that make a difference?