• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Which SSD for a Macbook Pro?

Could you not use the trim tool in bootcamp?

Not entirely clear if it would work for HFS partitions if you did and in my case it's a non starter, I don't use bootcamp, I don't need windows for anything. The idea that I install it so I can properly use a £300 SSD is beyond silly.

This one is apple's fault really, the non inclusion of trim in OSX is an issue, it's part of the ATA command set I believe so basically by not including it Apple aren't really properly implementing ATA.
 
Trim has only been adopted as the "correct" means of fixing the rewrite issue very recently, I'm sure it was just before SL came out basically when Microsoft implemented it.

Im sure it will feature in the next largish update.

Seriously just get an SSD you really wont regret it.
 
Well I'm sure I won't regret it in terms of performance but I don't want the hassle of reconditioning it every six months, if I don't do that then the benchmarks I've seen online suggest it'll degrade to the point of equivalence with a fast conventional drive.

Sure I won't be any worse off but I will be down £300. It's not a huge amount of money but I'm not wild about spending it when under these circumstances. There's always the option of upgrading later when trim support turns up I guess.

Or I could just bite the bullet and get one. If I do I'm thinking the Intel (basically on size grounds alone, the extra 30GB or so will likely be the difference between carrying an external drive around all the time and not for me.)
 
You don't have to recon them every 6 months. Write speed does degrade though - it really does depend how you use them.

Video here launching 50 odd apps on the Corsair unit I had before the Crucial - the Crucial is faster.


If you want to see stats on what write fatigue does have a look here: http://www.markc.me.uk/MarkC/Blog/Entries/2009/9/2_Crucial_M225_128Gb_SSD.html

If you want to see how to erase, have a look here: http://www.markc.me.uk/MarkC/Blog/Entries/2009/8/13_Erasing_an_SSD.html

Downside is you can't do a write erase on a Mac currently, to my knowledge anyways.
 
Are you buying the drive solely for the purpose of insanely fast write speeds then?

I wouldn't have though most people usage patterns involve a lot of sequential writing that wont be limited by the speed of its source.
 
Trim is a lot less of an issue than some people are making it out to be. The joy of an ssd isn't in the read or the write times; it's in the seek times. Consider how much money people spent on raptors for the decrease in seek times, and then look at the approximately 0ms seek for an ssd. Things are instant.

I concede that it'll read and write slower with time, but the seek time won't go up and that's why people love them so much. On the topic of reconditioning, I believe though am having a hell of a time verifying, that dd if=/dev/zero of=tmp && rm tmp does exactly the same thing. It's very difficult to find a straight answer on whether it takes longer to overwrite non-zero data than zero data, or whether there's some obscure 3rd state that exists before a zero is written to it. I really should bother testing this, but I just don't care enough to as my ageing vertex is still instantaneous :)
 
Back
Top Bottom