Will you require front facing 5¼ bays in your next case?

Soldato
Joined
31 May 2005
Posts
15,640
Location
Nottingham
I am seeing more cases with "fixed" fronts.

Perosnally, I have no problem with that.

I do not use optical drives nowadays (I have one from habit) but last two builds for other people have not had them.

I appreciate they are not ideal for those who need fan controllers and the such but I am happy to forego the 5¼ bay :D
 
Require, no, I don't deal with optical media on a daily or even weekly basis.

But it's convenient if I feel like watching a film from a disk or installing older programs from disk or giving a copy of something to someone in physical storage without having to give out a flash drive.

Current case has a door, and space inside, no issues. A future case would be the same.

On a new ITX build of small size I would be happy to compromise it out of the build.
 
With a dual front bay res and fan controller, yes I'll need 3.
But if I go back to air or aio with the next case (probably a few years), no.
 
No. I have a USB optical drive if required. Indeed, for an ITX build, I could manage with only 2.5" bays.
 
Will be phased out in the next 10 years surely. Laptops are getting to the point their that thin you can't fit one and PC's we build don't ship with one unless requested. USB drive if required.
 
I can't fathom why anyone would want 5¼ bays anymore, simply no need. I would never buy a case with them now. What device that goes there doesn't have a USB or other alternative?? Within a few years (hopefully sooner) I can see 5¼ bays going the way of 3½... I certainly hope so anyway.
 
I can't fathom why anyone would want 5¼ bays anymore, simply no need.
Because I have several 5.25" devices and mods, none of which are optical drives, but all of which are integrated elements of the design of the PC that works best for me.
If I had more bays, I'd have even more mods, but already I'm having to make do.
Besides, not everyone wants twenty USB cables snaking all over the place for external alternatives.
 
Because I have several 5.25" devices and mods, none of which are optical drives, but all of which are integrated elements of the design of the PC that works best for me.
If I had more bays, I'd have even more mods, but already I'm having to make do.
Besides, not everyone wants twenty USB cables snaking all over the place for external alternatives.


Yes, but you are very much in the minority. The way case design is going is clear evidence of that. Most people would just have a single DVD/BR drive and that's it, hardly the need for 20 USB cables lol!
 
Yes, but you are very much in the minority. The way case design is going is clear evidence of that. Most people would just have a single DVD/BR drive and that's it, hardly the need for 20 USB cables lol!
So?
You asked why anyone would want them and I am still someone.
My requirements may be different from "the majority", but why does that mean I can't or shouldn't still be catered for?

As is, I chose this case over many others precisely because it had four bays along with all the other required features. Now you want me with twin external USB drives, a USB fan controller, a USB reservoir, a USB card reader and fifteen other external USB devices, because there's no need to have them neatly housed internally?
 
The Workstations I build have recently been changed to chassis with NO 5.25" bays. Not a great deal of use for them any more. They make the cases smaller and there is no cabling to that area of the system. Its so much more sensible now to have a nice clean looking smaller system and have a external slim usb optical or card reader in a drawer for the once in a while use of them.
 
So?
You asked why anyone would want them and I am still someone.
My requirements may be different from "the majority", but why does that mean I can't or shouldn't still be catered for?

As is, I chose this case over many others precisely because it had four bays along with all the other required features. Now you want me with twin external USB drives, a USB fan controller, a USB reservoir, a USB card reader and fifteen other external USB devices, because there's no need to have them neatly housed internally?


The only external devices needed there would be the DVD drives, and they are so thin now they are hardly obtrusive, and the card reader, which you can get USB ones no bigger than a memory stick. All fan control can be done with software, or there's the internal Aquaero 6 LT USB, and there are obviously far better res options than the 5.25 bay ones. Not sure what 15 other devices you're talking about though.

I do see how YOU may need all those bays, but hardly anyone building a new system now would do that. Going forwards, 5.25 is dead. It will linger, just as 3.5 did, and some people will hang on, but eventually it will disappear altogether.
 
Well my 9 bays can fit 3.5" hard drives in 3x caddies, 9 x 5.25" drives, or any combination, and I guess if I wanted water cooling there's option for 5.25" self contained units (pump, resovoir and radiator) in that front bay area.
 
The only external devices needed there would be the DVD drives, and they are so thin now they are hardly obtrusive, and the card reader, which you can get USB ones no bigger than a memory stick. All fan control can be done with software, or there's the internal Aquaero 6 LT USB,
1/. I don't want cables trailing. End of. I don't care how few/many external USB devices you can name. I don't want that. My desk is cluttered enough and space is very limited. Thin still takes up a footprint. The whole point of this modding is to have things internally mounted and externally accessible.
2/. So five or six different USB card readers also needed.... Great, more expense.
3/. Fan control all with software - yes, and you also have an onscreen keyboard so you can do that with software too, but I don't see you chucking out your physical one... I want dials. It works best with me and my design.

and there are obviously far better res options than the 5.25 bay ones.
None of which look or do anything like the ones around which my PC has been designed and modded.
A big part of my reason for having a custom-build PC is all the things I can do with it, including the looks. Since we have so many cases with so many different designs and windows, I assumed that meant looks were important.... but if we're all going to have the exact same components and layouts with everything done by internal software, what's the point in even having different colour cases? Why aren't we all going back to boring white opaque boxes?

Not sure what 15 other devices you're talking about though.
Half of them are self-built mods using 5.25" drive casings. It's an easy housing to work with for people not already highly skilled in top end custom modding.
Others include things like DACs, hot-swap bays, switch panels and so on. Some people use things like OC Stations, too. Plenty of other things to use those bays.
As is, I've had to cut extra holes in my case to fit more things in.

I do see how YOU may need all those bays, but hardly anyone building a new system now would do that. Going forwards, 5.25 is dead. It will linger, just as 3.5 did, and some people will hang on, but eventually it will disappear altogether.
That doesn't mean it's better.
Touchscreens are everywhere, but we still have physical buttons on things like keyboards. If could get a mobile phone with a full size QWERTY still, I would. Touchscreen, supposedly "the way of the future", is a pain in the **** pile of stinking ****, with entire websites dedicated to the **** ups people have made with them.
Nothing wrong with including removable 5.25 cages to give people the choice... Just don't try forcing this **** on me.

Same for the trend of small, mini or micro cases with naff-all inside them - I actually want the stonking great huge cases, 900D or bigger, with loads of space for loads of modding.
 
Have them on my current case, but don't use them. So wouldn't bother me if my next didn't have them.

More bothered by windows being on basically everycase. Even my current case I had to buy the non-window side panel seperate. Don't want a window and you end up being massivly limited in what is available.
 
I have a fan controller that doubles as system diagnostics and power monitor/controller which is better than having it external and more useful than a software implementation. I'm in no hurry to see them go away even though I'd be happy enough to use an external optical drive the odd time I needed.
 
Back
Top Bottom