Windows Home Server: What to buy on a budget?

Soldato
Joined
24 Apr 2006
Posts
6,412
Location
SE England
I am after a new motherboard and CPU.. needs to be cheap!

Firstly here is what I am after

At least 6 onboard SATA ports
On board Gigabit LAN
2 or more PCI slots
On board GPU

The server will be used for file storage to uncompress RARs and rebuild via PAR files.

If it is a power efficient CPU then even better but again keeping cost down is key as most of my costs will be going towards hard drives expansion is also something key as I am going to want many drives for future use.

I started researching and quickly came across the AMD based Gigabyte GA-MA74GM-S2H Motherboard this seemed perfect as it has 6 SATA ports and is quite cheap. But then I started reading some people have issues with this motherboard and WHS to do with the drivers of the onboard SATA controller which uses two different controllers across the 6 ports. Issue with the drivers. Read all sorts of random blue screens and crashes... some have fixed it others I'm not so sure about... So that kinda put me off that mobo.

Then I came across this Intel motherboard Gigabyte GA-G31M-ES2L at a crazy price of a mere £30 brand new! For this price it isn't worth going second hand, only 4 port SATA though. Scanning over the net I can't seem to find any reports of problems with this motherboard and WHS. Also seems to get great reviews for such a budget board. I would probably stick a Intel Celeron Dual Core E1400 2GHz in it, would that be ok for what I want to do?

Any ideas for a case that could hold a fair few harddrives, say 12 for cheap?

Have I over looked any other cheap mobo options that have 6 port sata? My head is spinning abit from looking at spec sheets and googling. I know that WHS will run on almost any old hardware but I would like something that is going to be able to handle heavy downloading/decompressing and have abit of a future.

Thanks for your comments and advice in advance :)
 
Cheers guys

The Coolermaster Elite 335 case looks ideal.

I think I have decided on a GA-P31-ES3G as the mobo. Has 4 SATA ports but with 3 PCI and more importantly 3 PCIe slots for SATA controllers should cover the amount of drives I will want in the future.

AMD was tempting but the intel 755 socket route offers quite a large amount of upgrading with the CPUs so have gone with intel.

E8200 looks like it has amazingly low power consumption but is very over my budget!

I have decided on a Celeron 440, to be honest I'm not sure if it is going to be able to cut it for my needs being a single core, decompressing rars, downloading @ 6MB/s, and acting as a file server at the same time for music and video is quite demanding. But is pretty low power consumption and cheapish in the 2nd hand market, will see how it goes.
 
Last edited:
Well all ordered finally!

This is what I went for:

Celeron 440 2Ghz
Cooler Master 335 Elite Case
2GB DDR
Gigabyte GA-P31-ES3G iP31 Socket 775 5.1 channel audio ATX Motherboard
Samsung EcoGreen F2 1.5TB Hard Drive SATAII 32MB Cache
Akasa AK-956SF Socket 775 heatsink with fan Cooler
Powwa 600W 12cm Fan >80% High Efficiency PSU
HP ProCurve Switch 1400-8G
Linksys WRT54GL Wireless-G Linux Router
Plexus Cat5e UTP Patch Cable (Grey) 30m
Plexus Cat5e UTP Patch Cable (Red) 2m

After including the new gigabit switch and replacement WRT54GL router the total has come out to quite abit more money than was expecting!

Should all be here tomorrow so the fun will start :D
 
Install completed today :) So far I am loving it! The motherboard is perfect for WHS I had no problems what so ever, I didn't even need to supply SATA drivers on a floppy during installation, which I hear so much about.

CPU is coping.. it bottoms out reaching 100% usage during decompressing of RARs, was expected. I will have to see how that effects things when I get a HD streamer.

How much did to all come to out of interest?

Just the kit for the server of course.

Came to around £165 the 2GB RAM I already had and the CPU was purchased second hand.

CM335 is a good budget case for a server. You can fit 10 drives in with ease - it will take 11, but the 11th will be in a 'hot spot'

cm335a.jpg

My CM335 with the front removed and additional fans to cool the HD's
The 'hot spot' for HD's is the slot above the front USB ports. On mine that bay is empty and a 40mm fan is wedged in to blow across the HD.

I am really liking the case it has to be the best budget case I've ever bought. How do you manage to fit so many into the case?
 
Back
Top Bottom