Wireless speed troubles. Also does WinXP have a limit for the router channel selectable?

Associate
Joined
30 Aug 2007
Posts
111
I just upgraded my (Virgin Media) broadband to 30mb, but having a bit of trouble getting the best speeds throughout my network. One computer (running Windows 7) is connected to the super hub directly via an ethernet cable, and that gets the full 30mb on speedtest.

Another computer (also on W7) is using a wireless network card, and through testing each channel available on the router, I get around 17mb on the optimum channels (10 through to 13).

However on a third computer, which is old and still running XP, whenever I choose a channel 10 or above, it isn't able to detect the network at all. But as soon as I switch to channel 9 or below, it detects it and connects just fine. But then computer 2's speeds drop to below 10mb.

The network is nothing extraordinary, it's just a normal network within a household, so I don't think distance is a major factor here. The strange thing is that computer 2 and 3 both have the same network card, and I just updated the drivers for it yesterday. So I'm wondering if this is more to do with XP having some kind of limit on what channel it can detect. It's just right now if I use channel 9-, it's not really that great considering there's only one PC getting 30mb, and the rest are only getting 10mb and less.

-------edit-------

Could it be that my network cards are too old? I just connected my sister's laptop (Vista), which is about a year or two old, and that connected just fine and gets about 22mb. I've had my current network cards for god knows how long (could be 5-6 years now), so maybe they're just too old for these kinds of speeds? Also sorry for the insanely long post guys!
 
Last edited:
Afaik, the channels themselves don't determine the speed of the connection. The problem with the 2.4Ghz frequency band channels 1 through 13 is they overlap, which means if a close neighbour is broadcasting on 1, and you are on 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5, you may experience some interference, hence why selecting a non over lapping channel, 1, 6 or 11 can prove beneficial.

What are the wireless cards in your devices? What is the wireless network broadcasting compatibility on the router, ie, g, n or both?

Your wireless card must be 802.11 n compatible to achieve the best connection speeds, otherwise, a 802.11 g device may be the bottleneck.

edit: Just a theory, but try turning off bandwidth doubling on the router. Ie, set it to 20Mhz
 
Last edited:
^ this.

also For the info if your running B/G/N clients in a mixed environment the AP/Router has to step down to serve these slower speeds so a full n network is advised.

further more, reduce the power on the router wireless, the more networks it sees the more chance it will slow down when it sees a g client if its on your network or not !

give me a buzz if you want any more info, i do wireless stuff for a living :)
 
Bit of an update, we went out and got 2 new wireless cards. It solved the XP machine's problems. In fact the speeds it was getting was phenomenal - it gets 30-40mb on a 30mb connection! We did several tests and it was consistently better than even the wired connection. I really don't understand how.

Unfortunately the other computer didn't see such a vast improvement. In fact it seems to have gotten a little worse. Now it can only get around 14-17mb, and the signal only hovers around "good", despite being physically closer to the super hub.

I tried looking in the setup page to try switching it to 20mhz, but couldn't find that option.

-edit-

Finally got it all sorted now. Bought an extra TP-Link higher gain antenna (just 5dbi, the card is also a 2-antenna card but this works just fine with this plugged in with one other "normal" antenna), and now my wireless connection is excellent. Signal strength usually is excellent 5/5 bars, and very rarely does it go to 3/5 at the lowest, and speedtest shows 30mbps consistently.
 
Last edited:
Bit of an update, we went out and got 2 new wireless cards. It solved the XP machine's problems. In fact the speeds it was getting was phenomenal - it gets 30-40mb on a 30mb connection! We did several tests and it was consistently better than even the wired connection. I really don't understand how.

Unfortunately the other computer didn't see such a vast improvement. In fact it seems to have gotten a little worse. Now it can only get around 14-17mb, and the signal only hovers around "good", despite being physically closer to the super hub.

I tried looking in the setup page to try switching it to 20mhz, but couldn't find that option.

The 20Mhz thing was only a suggestion as to why a machine couldn't see beyond a certain channel. Irrelevant with new cards :)
 
Back
Top Bottom