WSUS, WDS or SCCM on hyper-v?

Soldato
Joined
30 Sep 2006
Posts
5,280
Location
Midlands, UK
Hi all,

I've asked a similar question before on here, but here's a more updated and detailed thread.

I'm in the midst of migrating our existing servers, both physical and virtual to a new beefy ML370 running 2008 Enterprise R2 (with hyper-v).
Currently i have a hyper-v instance that runs WSUS, which seems to work fine.
I recently installed WDS on another vm and had a very limited play on it.
I have also downloaded and installed the SCCM 2012 beta2 VHD onto a testserver.

1. WSUS seems to work without me having to know a great deal about it, but only does MS updates
2. WDS - i've only played with when thinking of deploying an image across 23 desktops (never bothered in the end), so still unducated with it.
3. Took one look at SCCM and realised i was way out of my depth, especially as my IT support company don't really have any experience with it, so i'd be flying blind.

Question is, although i'm not lazy and would relish the learning curve, i simply don't have time in my job to study and learn from scratch something so 'seemingly' massive as SCCM. Yet it seems like the right one to go for(?)

Can you guys give me some advice as to what you'd suggest using please?

We have approx, 7 servers, 30 desktops and 30 laptops across the business. There are quite a lot of installs that need to be deployed to each client but GPO just doesn't seem to work for most of them. In fact some software isn''t native .msi, so i used EXE>MSI converter and they still don't work.

Does WDS take care of MS updates and software deployment? And is SCCM just a bigger, better version of WDS?

Any and all advice would be most appreciated, thanks.
 
WDS = windows deployment service, basically a simple image deployment to clients, you make a master image then deploy to clients just like old ghost cast server.

WSUS = deploy updates/hotfixes etc etc to clients

MDT = microsoft deployment toolkit, an 'addon' tool onto WDS, deploy images and software to clients.

SCCM - system centre configuration manager, take control of everything, WDS, WSUS, MDT and few others onto single interface. hence the name.

edit: i never have any experience with SCCM so i'll let other people answer this. i like WDS with MDT very much. its recommend for small network
 
Last edited:
Sounds like for your environment a combination of WSUS for updates and WDS/MDT for builds/etc.

SCCM is really more an enterprise scale solution. Extremely powerful tool, costs quite a bit IIRC.
 
Or go for system center (sic) essentials :p

Not too expensive and designed for exactly this kind of thing, small deployments.

Gives you a lot of the benefits of SCCM with software deployment, asset management etc.
 
My production environment is roughly double the size of yours. I have virualised both our WDS and WSUS server. Both do their job perfectly.

I also currently use WININSTALL for software deployment and asset registering. Its powerful and handy but cumbersome and awkward at the same time. I'm looking into alternatives and will be trying MDT this coming week.

WDS, WSUS, MDT are all free. SCCM is not.
 
Back
Top Bottom