House Buying Woes...:(

Soldato
Joined
11 Dec 2003
Posts
21,634
Location
Sol
Hey all, we've had some major issues trying to buy a house this past month, basically as an investment to sell on, but I think if anything can go wrong, it has done, here's a rundown :(

Someone we know runs a company, if people need to sell thier house in a rush, be it divorce, illness, wanting to sell quickly etc.. then he will negotiate a price and pass the deal on the house down to people looking to buy a house as an investment (In this case, my partner & I)

So we agreed on going to get this one, i'm not going to put figures down, but it was being sold to us for 22% below market value (Valued in January and November of this year) which, after buying, paying mortgage on for a few months, and selling on, would make us a nice profit...

Oh dear...

So we arrange everything, mortgage, solicitor (for us and the sellers) all the usual shizzle that goes on, the mortgage broker tells us he wants to set us up on a residential mortgage, which would be fine, as we don't either own another home (This was pretty much done to give us a hefty lump to put down into our own place) everything goes well, mortgage application approved, solicitors informed, contracts being drawn up, which is when the mortgage advisor decides to tell us "Oh, you won't have to pay tax on this, and although you won't be living there, you **need** to make sure you let them know you have the intention of living in the house, otherwise you'll maybe be declined the mortgage. Ok then, so basically, our own mortgage advisor, from a respected company has drawn up a mortgage than we can only be eligible for, by lying to them, and risking getting a big black mark on our records for doing so, not good, obviously temptation is there as we REALLY need the money, but not so much that we'd risk ****** up our own future.

So we called inland revenue (We're both self employed, too) and stated what was happening, what had been advised, and basically said that we do not want to skip tax, we just wanted to see how best to go about things, what to do, who to let know what, and they basically told us to buy it, sell it, then declare it with earnings, less costs split 50/50 between us, and added to our self assessments, ok easy enough, thankyou!

Last thursday, the contracts arrived, and we were already having major doubts about this, the mortgage, although costing us nothing, deposit wise, was basically wrong, and we'd have to lie about it, which we are not prepared to do, queue the next the seller texts us saying that they have now moved out of thier house, and are in rented accomodation that they had lined up for after the sale. Well thats just great isn't it, they move out, before the sale completes, before they had even signed the damn contract, leaving us feeling guilty as hell, and them not knowing he we feel at all. Come monday morning, i called the mortgage company, and explained what we were told to say, by our broker, and that we did have no intention of moving into the place, but didn't want to have a fraudulant record struck against us, as, as soon as we had found out what was proposed, we were immediately unhappy with it.

Long story short, the mortgage company said that if that is the case, then they will withdraw thier offer, fair enough, thats a good thing right now really, as much as we want it, we don't want it THAT much. So we called around a few companies, and the only way really now would be to find an investor to stump up 15%, who would then take a rather large cut at the end.

Right now, i've just spoken to the seller informing her of what's happened, and she's obviously a bit peeved, obviously i didn't say anything about how she should have moved out AFTER the sale, but she was saying "But the completion date was meant to be the 17th..."

As much as i feel for her, and her husband, if she hadn't even SEEN the contract by the 17th, let alone not heard anything, its not really the wisest idea in the world to move out before the sale completes, if you're not going to be able to afford it.

I guess i just wanted to post this to get it off my chest, my girlfriend and I both feel really bad for this couple about how things have turned out, but at the same time, sales DO fall through all the time, and i'm severely peed off that she's complaining that she has already moved out, as she thought the completion date was the 17th...

Are we in the wrong here? We've tried to be as accomodating as we can for her, and at the end of the day, we didn't tell her to move out beforehand, infact we said she could stay on after complation if need be, we just didn't want to get any black marks against us that would ruin us ever getting our own mortgage, no cashback from a sale is worth that, and we just feel really guilty, confused, and peed off :(
 
Well you strike me as quite naive, you should have listened to your mortgage advisor. That is the done thing, you wouldn't be lying at all, like he said you simply have to say to the mortgage company you have the intention of living there. The mortgage company isn't interested whether you do or not, they wont ever find out or investigate. They only care that you make your payments. If they did find out, you wouldn't even get a black mark - it's a breach of contract, not a payment failure - they would try to fine you and maybe move you onto a different package or tell you to find another mortgage.

As for the other couple, well don't feel guilty as technically that's their mistake.
 
Seems like she was a bit hasty, you wouldn't buy a new car before the money was in the bank from the sale of the old one if you were tight for money, just common sence really, the sale is not a sale untill its all signed off.
 
lol.
normal thread:

OP: "this company send we this expensive item twice. should I keep the spare or send it back?"

others: send it back unless you have no morals, rawr!


ITT:

op:angelic behviour

others:
"omg you[op] are way too honest."
"you should intentionally lie to people who lend you tens of thousands of pounds"

gotta love forums :D

/me sits on the fence quitely
 
I wouldn't call declaring tax silly at all, we're not propared ot take the risk of it coming back to bite us in the arse at a later point, and also, lying about intentions with the property is not good, i called a colleague of my broker, with a query if I were to do that, and he said he would be 100% against it, and would never advise someone to do that as it is, quite frankly, illegal.

Straight down the line, or not at all, is how we planned and plan to do this thing.

The only question now, is as we are pulling out before signing anything, the only fees we should have to pay, are solicitors ones, as the mortgage broker has listed thier fees as payable upon completion.

In all honesty, we feel, after seeking professional advice, that the mortgage broker may have inflated our earnings when applying for the mortgage, 2 x £14,000 a year incomes, does not a £206,000 mortgage make.
 
Last edited:
Maybe next time you go for an easy buck, you should think about all the various assumptions and the risks of each one.

14 grand salary a year is a very poor financial position to be in to potentially be stuck with a property you cant shift .... to assume you can buy it and flog it straight away in this market is madness.

And morally, just remember what your trying to do is to make money out of a persons basic need (a roof over their head). Think about that one.
 
Perhaps it is unrealistic to be buying a property worth over £200k when your joint income is only £28k. What would you do if you could not sell? Would mean that not only would you be paying for your current accomodation you would be paying the mortgage payments on your investment. Your naivity is your downfall ... as a result of clearly not seeing something through, yet another buying is gazumped at the last minute.

Shame on you!

And my final thought ...

Mortgage lenders should not be allowed to give out such high mortgages to first time buyers!
 
Good on you for not taking the easy solution and lying.

In most cases, there's a reason why (for example) banks will not give you a BTL mortgage or whatever on the information provided.

It's quite possible that if you had taken the deal you shouldn't have been offered, it would have come back and bitten you later on.
 
I think you made the sensible choice, albeit leaving it a little bit late. No doubt both parties have now wasted several hundred pounds on fees :(
 
Personally,
I can't believe anyone would take on this amount of hassle and risk just for a quick few thousand.

As was said, the important thing here is there is no sure thing in being able to sell the house after you have bought it (or to definately sell it for a profit and make a few thousand) - What if you buy it and your area drops in price by 15% - Your 22% initial reduction would be barely anything after you'd paid all the mortgage/estate agent/stamp duty on the new house and solicitor bills and & what if you held it for longer than a few months because no one wanted to buy it ?

And i can't believe you just jumped into this kind of massive idea without reading, researching and reading all the outcomes again and again. It's not like it was a £50 IPOD you were buying. It was £200,000 and a few peoples lives that could potentially get wrecked if it all went pear shaped (including yours and your GF's)
 
aye i agreed few people above, it's daft to do this just for few £k, very complicated and anything could goes wrong.

bad way to invest me think
 
Well done to the OP for having the guts to call a halt to proceedings. Lots of people would have gone through with it, and landed themselves in hot water. Lucy escape if you ask me.

As the for the seller, anyone who moves out of a property before it is sold is an idiot. If she had bothered to ask her solicitor if this was a good idea before contracts had been even exchanged, he/she would have told her not to be a fool.

1 in 3 house sales fall through. She'll get over it. Hope you have more luck in the future.

I wonder how many of the people in this thread criticising you have bought and sold houses, I have and it is tricky and what you did took guts :)
 
Back
Top Bottom