Because if it was for me I would have taken the first one however it’s a gift so other people’s opinions would be useful.
But we only know you as a name on an internet forum, so even picking a watch for you would be difficult enough, how are we supposed to have a clue as to what your brother would like? For all we know he could be a camper than christmas, makeup wearing gayer that has a penchant for all things covered in diamante.
Maybe you should engage him in a bit of discrete conversation regarding watches and see if you could get an idea from him.


