a vent to asmosphre dump valve is basically for show, usually the air has been measured by the MAF and the ecu injects the corrosponding amount of fuel to air, but this air is vented to atmos so the rich mixture also causes flaming/popping etc, the best way is to have a recirc dumpvalve
What?
It completely depends on the car, the way the ECU takes its air flow readings, and the scenario in which its used. :/
A recirc diverter valve is needed on a 1.8T BECAUSE of the MAF, that isn't to say that for other cars, the "best" way is a recirc, because it isn't always the case.