I left eve over a year ago, this was a few months before the new battleships and when warp core stabs where common on all ships
The game got ****** with almost no pvp (it was getting worse and worse for 12months before), low sec was dead, 0.0 was dead, high sec was dead. You could not pvp alone or in small gangs for love nor isk.
the amount of time spent per kill was ridicules (ie in 4 hours you might get 2-3 kills looking hard, wow what fun, 3h for 3m of pvp).
When I left I had 45m skillpoints and was probably one of the top 100 in the game. I sold the character for 15B isk, which was a large sum for the time.
eve is crap for the following reasons. in no particular order
you join the game with 1m skillpoints and verse players with 50m skillpoints and perhaps the average pvp SP is 25-30m now? people say it dont matter but it sure does, i would know!
pod kill prices. why do higher SP players pay 15m per pod kill? it meant I was never in a t1 frig or a t1 gear just because the pod costs so much
t2 : so many problems, the major one being market manipulation and a few ultra rich individuals/corps
no pvp. Everyone plus dog is scared in eve, no one fights unless they outnumber you 4 to 1.
no incentives for low sec living.
lots and lots and lots of problems
imo, 80-90% of people who "play" eve are just logging on to chat with friends 80-90% of the time. nothing else