Ok I wa splaying this until 4am last night and have just got onto the start pf the space stage here are my thoughts...
- Cell stage is fun but a bit pointless imo, very simplistic and doesn't really add much to the game. Takes a bit long too, which means it can get repetitive.
- Creature stage is a good laugh but I found certain aspects a bit confusing at first... such as some part of the communication/relationships not being consistent (sometimes I could charm my guys instantly, other times only the right side fo the pink friend-o-meter went up and the left stayed down. Why? Either way it was fun building up my creature and giving it uber abilities before taking my pack out on a rampage... I highly reccommend the best pair of wings beore you move to tribal stage... it makes you bad-ass!
- Tribal stage was again good fun... but it doesn't really encourage co-operation with other tribes... it's much less hassle (and much more fun) to just go and wipe them all out. Either way there's no challenge or strategy to it, it's just the visual charm that gets you through.
- Civilization stage was quite fun with designing your own ships and houses... but again I think that after a while this would get very very old... going forward for future games they need to implement some sort of auto-build optionto stop it getting too tiring. The gameplay in this bit again had very little challenge... just get all your cities to 1200+ incomem build enough turrets, spam enough powerful air units, and you'll be fine. Again, very little strategy.
- Space stage... i'lll tell you soon... just started it but so far seems interesting enough and my ship does look awesome.
I really think this game is one that will get better as content is released... I think it was a great and ambitious concept that couldn't quite be implemented how thy wanted, and that extra content and patches will bring it into its own. However immediate concerns are a real lack of strategy and substance underneath some of the stages... I didn't quite get that sense that I was a God doing epic things. I wanted to see more interaction with the populace, and see the effect my decision have on them on a more personal level... something I don't feel that the Tribal or Civ stages let me do. I want Black & White style detail.
Visually the game looks fantastic... it's got one of those 3D engines that you can't just help but love, everything is rendered properly and it all runs butter smooth on my ageing 8800GT at 1680*1050. No complaints there at all.
We'll see how it goes... but the fact I was up till 4am last night playing it and had no idea where the time went (
time junmped 2 hours each time I glanced at the clock lol) bodes wel. I hope they make something ogf the game, or even ensure that they learn from any drawbacks of this game and make Spore 2 a true 'evolution' of the genre.