Auto Voice Censoring on XBL and Elsewhere

Soldato
Joined
4 Aug 2006
Posts
7,898
Location
Stevenage , Wisbech
What are peoples feelings on this?
Back in 2004 Microsoft applied for a patent for real-time censoring of audio streams, and now the USPTO has granted that patent.

As PC gamers have known for a long time, and Xbox gamers have known for a while, playing against other humans online is a much more enjoyable experience than beating a computer. Thanks to the advent of teamspeak, you can game with others as if they were in your living room, without having to worry about them knocking their drinks over and staining the carpet. However, the somewhat anonymous nature of the internet means you also encounter individuals who lack the sort of internal filter that prevents most of us from blurting out streams of profanity that would make Mr. Tourette blush.

More often than not, the profanasaurus on the other end of the mike is a schoolboy still at the age where yelling random insults at strangers seems amusing, but it only takes one moron to spoil a good time. The patent involves real-time (or batch) analysis of an audio stream that can recognize inappropriate language based on phonemes, and then overwrite objectionable words with bleeps, other noises, or silence.

But online gaming isn't the only area where this technology could show up. TV networks, fearing hefty FCC fines, would be able to broadcast live without fear of exposing the sheltered ears of their audience to a (possibly life altering) outburst or expletive. No more seven-second delay with an editor's finger hovering over the bleep button, no more being raked over the coals by the Parents Television Council, no more ****s, ****s, or ************** ********** slipping into the next award show.

I can also envisage a more sinister role, however, regardless of one's opinion on whether or not those seven words ought to be allowed to be said on television. Imagine the same system applied to digital telephony, then think how valuable such a system might be to an authoritarian regime. As we've seen to good effect in Burma and elsewhere, the ubiquity of cell phones has been a good thing for dissidents who need to get their message out or organize themselves. The Great Firewall of China already blocks objectionable web content from reaching Chinese computers; what's to stop cell phones from censoring anti-government conversations too?

I see how its a good idea, but then im not a great fan of being told what i can and cannot say when im talking to people of my own age group. For PG rated games with online then i think its a good idea, but say for an 18 rated game then it shouldnt be used.
Does any one think it will censor the words Nintendo wii, Sony Playstation, RROd and Apple?:D
 
can only be a good thing for younger gamers, so long as you can control it in the parental settings and turn it off when the grown ups are playing then im all for it
 
If it stops the annoying american 12 year old that you always get on COD4 games shouting about how we're all those of a coloured nature, I'm for it :p
 
How does this work in "real-time" Surely you have to say part or most of the offending word before it can blank/beep it so there has to be a slight delay. It's like that crap in Star Trek. When they press communicator button, how does it automatically know who to patch into until they speak or say the name, which implies a delay.

I like the idea from a Parental guidance/controls point of view as there is far too much swearing and racism on Xbox Live tbh.


rp2000
 
If it stops the annoying american 12 year old that you always get on COD4 games shouting about how we're all those of a coloured nature, I'm for it :p

There is barely a lobby I enter where one american or another is not using ****** as a term to go on the attack.

I was chatting to wyrdo and wiggis about this the other day. Ms already have a system to cut this out. They have zones. If i'm in the underground and someone calls me a ****ing ****** so be it. The warning for underground already states it may contain bad language.

These players should not be matched to family rooms unless invited.

Why even come up with the zones if they allow every one to be matched.

If someone is repeatedly getting bad feedback for language in a family zone they should be banned from the family zone.
 
How does this work in "real-time" Surely you have to say part or most of the offending word before it can blank/beep it so there has to be a slight delay.
Agreed... if I were to scream "Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu..." (and I regularly do) how does it know if I'm going to end it with "...dge" or "...ck"? It can't.

As for the Star Trek... that's quantum magik... obviously.
 
There is barely a lobby I enter where one american or another is not using ****** as a term to go on the attack.

That would be solved with an "Auto Mute Americans" option on the dashboard. Much simpler technology. If only you could download dashboard mods - that's one I would write.
 
Heheh... was that then we all changed our tags to be IRAQ, IRAN, ARAB etc... heheh.. funneh American abuse follows. I changed mine to be USA and joined in with them :D

Yup. Proper funny night :cool:

Conversation between me and a yank:

yank: are you from Iraq?
Me: Durka Durka
Yank: do you wanna be my friend?
Me: Abaka-la
 
A simple solution is to just switch the voice setting to 'Friends Only' so you can only hear the people on your friends list. After that you don't have to listen to those jackasses who insist on play their **** music full blast down the headset.
 
A simple solution is to just switch the voice setting to 'Friends Only' so you can only hear the people on your friends list. After that you don't have to listen to those jackasses who insist on play their **** music full blast down the headset.

People don't like to hear my iTunes collection in grainy quality sound :confused:


rp2000
 
Back
Top Bottom