Pirate bay court case

A Swedish court has convicted four men linked to the popular Pirate Bay file-sharing site of breaking Sweden's copyright law.

The Stockholm district court sentenced Gottfrid Svartholm Warg, Peter Sunde, Fredrik Neij, and Carl Lundstrom to one year each in prison.

They were also ordered to pay damages of 30 million kronor ($3.6 million) to a series of entertainment companies, including Warner Bros, Sony Music Entertainment, EMI and Columbia Pictures.

The Pirate Bay provides a forum for its estimated 22 million users to freely download music, movies and computer games through so-called torrent files. The site has become the entertainment industry's enemy No. 1 after successful court actions against file-swapping sites such as Grokster and Kazaa.

More info ^
 
bump for this thread.

All 4 accused found guilty. $3.6 million fine and 1 year in prision.

Now the appeals start.

That sucks for them.

As mentioned earlier in the thread though, surely they should be going after the release groups, not the torrent sites surely?

Removing the source is surely the best option if they are serious which I highly doubt.
 
Last edited:
That sucks for them.

Has mentioned earlier in the thread though, surely they should be going after the release groups, not the torrent sites surely?

Removing the source is surely the best option if they are serious which I highly doubt.

That's close to impossible.
 
Now that I cannot wait to see, would love the MPAA try to take down that monster.

Why do you think theyve not touched it soo far? Because they know it is going to be a long battle they may not win.

Exactly, they wouldn't win it, there's just no point.

Probably. In which case rather than taking people to court they need to think of other means.

People have been racking their brains for years to think of other means. No-one's come up with an answer. Taking down The Pirate Bay was just taking down four easily-traceable criminals who had a large impact on illegal downloading. It won't make any difference to sharing overall from now on, people will just go elsewhere.

The only way to stop downloading is for ISPs to force 28k on all connections. But that'll never happen.
 
Exactly, they wouldn't win it, there's just no point.



People have been racking their brains for years to think of other means. No-one's come up with an answer. Taking down The Pirate Bay was just taking down four easily-traceable criminals who had a large impact on illegal downloading. It won't make any difference to sharing overall from now on, people will just go elsewhere.

The only way to stop downloading is for ISPs to force 28k on all connections. But that'll never happen.

Exactly, Napster got shutdown and that was the end of all piracy as we knew it................................. Oh wait...
 
going after piratebay is just working backwards..

its the suppliers who upload illegal content that should be targeted

if piratebay go, then someone else will take their place

reminds me of the law on drugs.. just say NO.. (doesnt work)
 
Exactly, Napster got shutdown and that was the end of all piracy as we knew it................................. Oh wait...
What this does is send out a message that if you host a torrentsite you can get a prison sentence and a big fine, that should stop some sites from starting or continuing, just look at Torrentspy stopping because of the threat of court action.
 
I can imagine Emule/Donkey making a resurgence to be honest.

Gah I hope not. One thing that surprises me about 'traditional' P2P (as opposed to BitTorrent) is that it never really improved after Napster and indeed seemed to get worse. I suppose it's because people moved on to Usenet and torrents, but I'm still surprised it never really got going after that initial burst.
What we really need is something like Freenet, but fast. A torrent site hosted on there isn't going to be taken down.
 
What this does is send out a message that if you host a torrentsite you can get a prison sentence and a big fine, that should stop some sites from starting or continuing, just look at Torrentspy stopping because of the threat of court action.

Exactly, I know a couple of sites - one which was a major - which were shut down because of this.

It will just route it down other avenues as we all know.

I can imagine Emule/Donkey making a resurgence to be honest.

Not so sure about that since the raids. And they're starting to use monitoring software along the lines of LimeWire now. DC++ is another matter.
 
Back
Top Bottom