Surround headsets roundup, including Psyko Acoustics 5.1 headset, Megalodons G35 etc

Soldato
Joined
15 Jan 2006
Posts
7,812
Location
Derbyshire
http://www.tomsguide.com/us/Surround-Sound-Headsets,review-1357-6.html

I know how much ridicule any mention of surround headsets gets, but I'd encourage people to be open minded about such things. The reviews aren't in-depth at all really but it's the first glimpse of a proper review of the Psycho Acoustics 5.1 headset. I am interested to see that they rate it above the Logitech G35 which is Dolby Headphone based. At a glance - I think they've over-rated most of the headsets. I think they've missed a trick by not including an X-Fi or Xonar with stereo headphones in the roundup - I suspect they would slaughter most of these combos.

I'm the first to admit that to date 5.1 headsets haven't been good enough. The psyko's a unique design though. It's significantly different enough from the Medusas etc for me not to automatically dismiss it and they rate it as giving the best surround effect here. Personally I wouldn't knock it until an audiophile review site has tried it. No way I'm buying a set at $300 though so unlikely to try it myself.
 
I'm yet to find a surround headset that can beat a high end pair of stereo headphones and dolby headphone, CMSS-3D or some form of HRTF. And I've been through a good few sets of surround headphones.
 
I won't completely dismiss 5.1 headsets as there are people on headfi who use them and all the good reviews i've read have always put them slightly ahead on positional sound compared to good stereo headphones like 595s.
Though it's always been that the headsets only hold their own in positional gaming sound everywhere else the proper headphones trounce them.

The Pschos look interesting but it seems to me that transporting the sound via air pipes leaves the possibility of external conditions effecting the sound.
 
I'm yet to find a surround headset that can beat a high end pair of stereo headphones and dolby headphone, CMSS-3D or some form of HRTF. And I've been through a good few sets of surround headphones.

I agree, at least since X-fi. I never found CMSS-3d on Audigy particularly good and I rate the Medusas higher than the Audigy iCMSS-3d implementation.

One area where I can't see the Psykos beating Dolby Headphone is bass soundstaging. Dolby Headphone, particularly DH3, convincingly renders bass sounds as distant from the head. As the psykos use bass drivers next to the ears, rather than the headband I don't see how it will acheive this.
 
uhm compare that to a HD595 or HD25, DT770 for gamers and bahm, we're back to stereo....

I had one of the medusa 5.1 headsets. man was I glad when i ebayed it and bought the 595s. And those arent even considered that great on headfi. But then those guys are crazy.

Now i have a DAC for my sound from my pc and my headphones go through my NAD amp. Not exactly high end but it sounds very nice
 
Back
Top Bottom