I wish I hadn't watched the first video. Michael Madsen has doomed me to probably a year of feverish waiting... curse you, Michael Madsen!
For some reason it still looks more like a single player offline RPG to me than a massive multiplayer one.
The voice over thing is a waste of effort, can't see them putting in the work to keep it up as they add content and all it does is massively slow down interactions with NPC's, EQ2 uses it for some stuff and you can read the text way quicker so most people just do that and skip the voice over, and that's when they can be bothered to read the text instead of just clicking through it.
The open combat scenes seem no different to me than any other mmo I have played. The maps look huge
Looks very different to the MMOs that I play..the "open" combat scenes..I dont know..they just look heavily instanced to me. Obviously its early days so they dont have loads of people around, but the question for me is will they be having it "open" or heavily instanced.
Will there be hundreds of people in the same area, or will it be instanced with just your group?
If its not instanced, how will the story be told?
What happens if I group up with people on a quest to kill some dark side guy, but at the last minute I decide that I dont want to kill the guy, I want to join him and keep him alive so I wait for my group to engage him and then help him by attacking my group ? Can I do that? Or is it that you "have" to follow the scripted good guy/bad guy storyline once you are in one with a group?
Could just be me being cynical, but it does seem to me that its essentially something very similar to City of Heroes or Guild Wars or something rather than what I consider an "open" MMO.
For some reason it still looks more like a single player offline RPG to me than a massive multiplayer one.
I don't care about cut scenes or voice acting. Don't want to be a "Star Wars hero right from the beginning". I want PvP. 
Fail!PVP options?? anyone know if this game has any
THat was the defining part of SWG, if this follows a similar route ill be very interested.
Im still hugely into eq2 as no other MMO has done it as good in the previous 5 years...
.