Canon Speedlite Alternatives?

Soldato
Joined
26 Jan 2003
Posts
3,704
Location
Nottm
Hello all,

I want a Canon Speedlite either 430EXii or the 580EX however I can't justify the cost at the moment so I was wondering if anyone has used an alternative brand flash AND a Canon Speedlite to compare against and what the outcome was like.

Cheers,
 
Check out the Sigma range of Flashguns, I have used these in various guises and tbh they are not bad but certainly cheaper than the Canon guns.
 
I just bought a Canon 430EZ for £45 off auction, and looking at getting another for a similar price.

Very similar spec to the 430EX, only difference is that it won't work in E-TTL, which for me is no issue as I'll be triggering it wirelessly anyway and I prefer to have manual control over the power :)
 
I've got a 580EX and a couple of older flashes - a 540EZ and a Nikon SB28 (or 26, can't remember which).

Working wireless off camera, it makes no great difference. If you're looking to save the beer tokens, it'd be hard not to recommend a cheap ebay flash and a set of ebay triggers.
 
I'd be mounting this on the top of the camera, when I move out and when finances allow I'll be getting some wireless triggers with cheaper flashes in.

Them Sigma flashes look decent, what's the main differences between the SUPER and the DG ST?
 
I'd be mounting this on the top of the camera, when I move out and when finances allow I'll be getting some wireless triggers with cheaper flashes in.

Them Sigma flashes look decent, what's the main differences between the SUPER and the DG ST?

The dg st only fits Nikons i believe. Don't quote me on it though.
 
the standard (ST) models, features full exposure automation, full auto-zoom function and ease of operation, and the Super models, having the same power and automation, but with more user control, and adding many extra, creative functions, including the very latest technology and features, such as Wireless TTL Exposure control, High Speed (FP) synchronization, Distance information functions, Modeling Light, Wireless Slave functions


The Super:
Auto-zoom function for changing the illumination angle
This function automatically sets the optimum illumination angle in accordance with the lens' focal length, in a range from 24 mm to 105 mm. When the built-in Wide Panel is used, the flash can cover the angle of up to that of a 17mm lens.
Automatic TTL exposure control supporting a diverse array of illumination methods
Various forms of illumination, such as the diffusion effect achieved by attaching a diffuser to the flash head. Bounce flash, using a reflector, without directly illuminating the subject with flash light, can be accomplished, while maintaining automatic exposure control.
Bounce-flash function with movable flash head
The flash head can be tilted up by up to 90 degrees, to the left by 180 degrees, or to the right by 90 degrees. Bounce photography, in which light is reflected off a white wall or the ceiling or a reflector, increases your range of photographic expression. As the flash head can also be tilted down by 7 degrees, light can be effectively used even for close-up shots.
Wireless-slave-flash functions
The EF-530 DG SUPER provides the TTL wireless-slave-flash functions, which allows the flash to be moved to a location away from the camera for operation. The TTL wireless-flash function enables the control of multiple EF-530 DG SUPER units while preserving the automatic TTL control function. The model for Sigma, Sony and Pentax uses the camera's built-in flash for signalling, and makes the EF-530 DG SUPER located away from the camera to fire. The model for Canon utilises an EF-530 DG SUPER mounted on the camera for signalling, and triggers and controls single or multiple EF-530 DG SUPER units, located away from the camera. In this procedure, the signalling and flash triggering are performed by changing the settings of the EF 530 DG SUPER mounted on the camera. The Designated Slave-flash function triggers multiple, units of the EF-530 DG SUPER, each corresponding to a preset channel (with manual exposure control). The Normal Slave-flash function can be used to synchronize one or more EF-530 DG SUPER flashes with the camera's internal flash or other flash equipment (with manual exposure control).
Modelling flash function to check for shadows
Like a studio flash unit equipped with a modelling lamp, the EF-530 DG SUPER also offers a modelling flash function, enabling the user to check for intense reflections and shadows, before actually taking the flash picture. (for Sigma, Sony, Canon, and Pentax cameras).
FP flash function for high shutter speeds
For focal-plane shutters, the flash synchronization speed is limited to coincide with full shutter opening, thus limiting the use of high shutter speeds with flash. The FP Flash function makes flash photography possible at shutter speeds greater than the normal synchronization speed. When the lens diaphragm is set to larger apertures to limit depth of field in synchronized daytime shooting, high shutter speeds can be used to balance the daylight and the flash light, at any shutter speed.
Rear-curtain synch flash mechanism for natural representation of motion
When shooting a moving subject in slow synch photography, selection of the rear-curtain synch mode allows the flash to be triggered immediately before the rear-curtain of the shutter closes. Unlike front-curtain synch, this mode records blurred trails behind the subject rather than in front, for a more natural expression of motion.
A full range of advanced functions
The EF-530 DG SUPER is packed with convenient functions, including the "Multi-Pulse Flash Function," which exposes a series of images onto a single frame, and the "Auto Power-Off Function," which automatically shuts off the power. It also features a red-eye reduction function, an exposure compensation function, an exposure-control checking function, and many others.


The ST:
Auto-zoom function for changing the illumination angle
This function delivers flash light by automatically setting the optimum illumination angle, in accordance with the lens' focal length, in a range from 24 mm to 105 mm. When used with the built-in Wide Panel, the flash can cover the angle of up to 17-mm ultra wide-angle lens.
Automatic TTL exposure control
Advanced photographic techniques, such as diffused lighting photography with a diffuser attached to the flash head, or bounce photography with the light pointed at the ceiling or wall to soften the shadows cast on the subject without directly illuminating the subject with flash light, can be performed while the automatic exposure control function is preserved.
Bounce flash function, with movable flash head
The flash head can be tilted up by up to 90 degrees, to the left by 180 degrees, or to the right by 90 degrees. Bounce photography, in which light is reflected off a white wall or the ceiling or a reflector, increases your range of photographic expression. As the flash head can also be tilted down by 7 degrees, light can be effectively used even for close-up shots.
Auto Power-Off function prevents wasted power
Even if the flash is left with the power on, it automatically shuts off if it is not operated for a certain length of time. This conserves battery power in flash photography. When the shutter button is depressed halfway, the power turns on again and charging resumes.
Diverse, user-friendly functions
Manual flash mode with two levels: Full power and 1/16 power. The display function indicates the completion of recharging and allows the TTL exposure control to be checked using the Ready light. The focal-length display shows the current focal-length setting of the zoom head. This flash features many other functions as well.
To name but a few differences between the ST and the Super :)

I have used both the Sigma and the Canon and there really isn't that much between them apart from cost of course. The modelling light is a handy feature too :D
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom